Tuesday, July 14, 2015

What’s 5,000 pages long and costs Rs 44,198...?

Bangalore Mirror: Bangalore: Tuesday, July 14, 2015.
A document running up to 22,000 pages at a cost of Rs 44,198 has set the record for being the most voluminous document ever issued under the Right To Information (RTI) by the anti-corruption watchdog institution Lokayukta.
Even the illegal mining report that shook the political establishment in the state ran up to just a little over 5,000 pages. This document pertains to the statement of assets and liabilities submitted by 225 MLAs (Members of Legislative Assembly) and also includes details about a few incumbent MLAs from the day they took office years ago.
The colossal document was handed over in June to an RTI and social activist Abraham T J who had sought details on MLAs for not only this year but throughout their career as incumbents ever since the Lokayukta institution came into existence in 1985, a senior official with the Lokayukta told Bangalore Mirror.
Although the submission of statement of assets and liabilities was required ever since the anti-corruption watchdog institution came into existence, it had become mandatory with awareness and sensitisation during the tenures of recent Lokayuktas, especially during Justice M N Venkatachala's and Justice N Santosh Hegde's tenures, an officer explained.
"The applicant had sought every detail on statement of assets and liabilities the organisation had. This included details of some MLAs who are not members only this time, but are being elected for up to eight terms continuously. In such cases, the details of the statement from day one till date of the RTI application has been provided," an officer told Bangalore Mirror.
The document mainly comprises of affidavits and has been issued upon payment of Rs 44,198.
The assets and liabilities statements include details of movable and immovable assets and liabilities each year over the years the MLAs.
The A (assets) and L (liabilities) statement is considered the basis for assessing or evaluating the rise or fall in assets, which can then be determined as proportionate or disproportionate to known sources of income.
Disproportionate assets to the known source of income of an MLA could land that particular MLA in trouble.
However, the only action under Lokayukta act pertaining to this issue is publishing in newspapers the names of such MLAs for either failing to provide or providing incorrect information.
But, they can be prosecuted under the Prevention Of Corruption Act under section 13 (1) (e) read with 13 (2) of PC act 1988, for disproportionate assets to the known source of income.
"Some applicants had expressed concern over the availability of assets and liabilities statements under RTI. But with this, a message has been sent that we will provide any document that could be shared with anybody under the RTI Act. In this case, it was a tedious task as we had to gather information of every term of every MLA. Some include those who were elected then lost and then were re-elected. All these details were collated and given to the RTI applicant," the official explained.
The Lokayukta official said just like Abraham many other activists too have applied for documents and all would be provided with the required documents.