Thursday, November 19, 2026

Manipur’s displaced families deserve to know where relief funds go : Naorem Mohen

India Today NE: Opinion: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
At Manipur University, Prof. Khelena Gurumayum asked whether citizens can find out how rehabilitation money is spent and who receives assistance. The answers matter in a state where years of violence and displacement have eroded public trust.
When a rehabilitation package is announced, a displaced family in Manipur has immediate questions. Do we qualify for help to rebuild our home? Has our application been processed? If it is still pending, who can tell us why? The answers may determine where the family will live and whether its children will have to change schools again. It should be able to get those answers without making repeated trips to a district office.
At Manipur University’s November 18 awareness programme on the Right to Information Act, political scientist Prof. Khelena Gurumayum connected those questions to a basic principle of democracy. Elections give citizens a say in who exercises public power. Between elections, citizens must be able to ask those in authority to account for their decisions. Information held by public institutions, she argued, is a public resource. In Manipur, where violence since May 2023 has uprooted families, disrupted livelihoods and strained relations between citizens and the state, access to that information has particular weight.
The programme also marked the release of an RTI handbook for Central Public Information Officers (CPIOs) and First Appellate Authorities (FAAs). The release gave practical expression to the programme’s theme of strengthening transparency and accountability in public institutions. Information officers must help applicants, locate records and respond clearly.
Appellate authorities must examine whether a refusal or an inadequate reply can be justified. The handbook’s value will be measured in how those duties are carried out, whether the person seeking an answer is a student asking about examination rules or a displaced parent trying to find out where a housing claim stands.
Follow the money to the household
Gurumayum Khelena asked how much had been sanctioned for relief and rehabilitation, how much had been released and how the government was assessing whether its programmes were working. These are questions for taxpayers as well as displaced families. The answers would help the public judge whether assistance is reaching eligible households fairly across districts and communities.
The Union Ministry of Home Affairs records that it released ₹229.25 crore to Manipur in 2024–25 to operate relief camps. Its 2025–26 special package lists ₹119 crore in additional housing support for 7,000 households, at ₹1.70 lakh per household over and above the Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana–Gramin grant. Manipur’s government should make the next part of the record easy to follow. How much did each district receive and spend? How many households received payments? How many claims are pending, and for how long? Where housing payments have been made, how many homes have been completed?
Gurumayum Khelena also stressed the dignity and privacy of displaced people. The state can publish district-wise expenditure, eligibility rules and the number of households assisted while giving families a private way to check their own claims. If an application is held up, the family should be told the reason and whom to contact. In a state where rumours about who received help can deepen mistrust between communities, verifiable public records give people a common basis for questioning how relief is distributed.
A portal is only the beginning
Poor record-keeping, delayed replies, backlogs at information commissions and refusals with inadequate explanations were among the problems Prof Khelena identified. An online portal can make an RTI request easier to file and track. A timely, useful reply depends on whether the responsible office can locate the record and provide it in a form the applicant can use. Section 4 of the RTI Act requires public authorities to maintain records and proactively disclose specified information. For relief schemes, the state should explain eligibility, application procedures and where to seek help at camps and district offices as well as online.
Gurumayum Khelena drew attention to women who have organised relief, cared for displaced people and worked for peace since the conflict began. She asked what empowerment means in practice for a woman who is herself displaced or facing financial hardship. Can she find out what assistance she qualifies for? Can she question a delay and receive an answer? Access to that information gives her a way to claim her entitlements and hold the responsible office to account.
Manipur University can start with its own records
A publicly funded university that encourages students to think critically, Khelena said, should be prepared to answer legitimate questions about its own decisions. At the programme, Dr Sakila Nongmeikapam, the university’s Public Relations Officer and Central Public Information Officer, reported that Manipur University scored 67.5 per cent in its first third-party RTI transparency audit for 2025–26. She called for better record-keeping, closer coordination between departments and more regular updates to the university website. Publishing the steps taken after the audit would allow students, staff and applicants to see what has improved.
Controller of Examinations T. Shantikumar Singh gave a practical example. Students sometimes seek re-evaluation when the university’s rules provide for re-scrutiny, which checks for unmarked answers and errors in totalling or carrying forward marks. A clear notice on the examination portal could explain what students can apply for and how.
Prof. Yumnam Premananda Singh, Head of Manipur University’s Department of Law, urged information officers to help applicants who cannot put an RTI request in writing. That assistance is a legal duty. Under Section 6(1) of the Right to Information Act, the Central or State Public Information Officer must provide reasonable assistance to put an oral request in writing when the applicant cannot do so.
The Act also sets out what an officer must tell an applicant when a request is rejected. Under Section 7(8), the officer must give the reasons for the rejection, the deadline for filing an appeal and the details of the appellate authority. For a displaced person seeking records on rehabilitation spending or the status of a housing claim, these safeguards matter at both ends of the process. They help the person get the request on record and know where to turn if access is refused.
Registrar and First Appellate Authority Prof. M. Premjit Singh stressed the importance of recording the reasons for decisions when they are made. In an RTI appeal, a clear record helps the appellate authority examine how the original decision was reached and whether the applicable rules were followed. It also gives the university a basis for explaining its decision to the person affected.
Vice-Chancellor Prof. R.K. Hemakumar Singh called on departments to share responsibility for maintaining the records needed to answer RTI requests. An information officer can coordinate a reply, but the department that made the decision often holds the relevant files. Whether the university can give a student or staff member a complete answer depends on how well each department keeps its records.
How transparency can earn trust
Finance Officer Prof. L. Rajendrakumar Singh recalled an administrative culture in which decisions were made behind closed doors and files moved from table to table while citizens waited. Without access to the records behind a decision, people struggled to challenge delays, favouritism or misuse of public funds. He described the way forward in three words, “transparency, trust, and transformation.” When officials know that decisions about purchases, expenditure or examinations can be scrutinised, he argued, they have a reason to keep accurate records and explain how they applied the rules. Citizens can then judge for themselves whether an institution acted fairly.
Rajendrakumar linked stronger implementation of RTI to the need to restore people’s faith in Manipur’s public institutions. Rehabilitation offers a practical test. If the same problem is holding up dozens of housing claims, the administration can use its records to identify where the process breaks down and fix it.
For a displaced family, the change will be felt in an ordinary exchange at a district office. The family asks what happened to its application. An officer opens the record, explains where the claim stands and says who is responsible for the next step. After years of uncertainty, a family should be able to count on that answer.
Manipur University’s November 18 programme brought the Right to Information Act into the everyday work of public institutions. A student asking how examination marks were checked and a displaced family trying to find out where its housing application stands are both entitled to a clear answer.
Giving that answer begins long before anyone files an RTI request. It begins when an office records why it made a decision, keeps that record accessible and takes responsibility for explaining it. That was the practical lesson of the Manipur University programme, and it is one that every public institution in Manipur can act on.
Edited By: Aparmita

CIC Directs GeM to Disclose Cartelisation Findings

Rediff Money: New Delhi: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
CIC orders GeM to reveal internal findings on cartelisation, market concentration, and repeat seller orders after GeM cited commercial confidentiality under RTI.
The Central Information Commission (CIC) has directed the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) to provide an RTI applicant general findings of its internal assessments on cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, after the platform acknowledged analysing repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers but refused to disclose related reports.
GeM, launched by the Centre on August 9, 2016, is an online platform for the procurement of goods and services by government ministries, departments, public sector undertakings and other government organisations.
The RTI applicant had also asked about a purported "link facility" through which procurement or bid links were allegedly sent to selected sellers. GeM, however, denied the existence of any such facility on its portal.
In an order, Information Commissioner Khushwant Singh Sethi directed GeM to provide the general findings emerging from its reports, reviews or risk assessments concerning cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, if any, maintained by it.
The applicant, Goutam Mohanta, had specifically sought copies of reports, reviews or risk assessments maintained by GeM concerning cartelisation, concentration of procurement orders among sellers and creation of entry barriers.
The CIC directed the platform to "provide a specific and point-wise reply" indicating the findings emerging from these reports, reviews or risk assessments, if any.
The direction came after GeM, in response to another part of the RTI application, acknowledged that it conducts internal analysis regarding repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers or groups of sellers.
However, it refused to disclose the related reports, claiming that the information was commercially confidential and market-sensitive.
GeM invoked Section 8(1)(d) of the RTI Act, 2005, to deny the information, stating that its disclosure was likely to adversely affect the competitive position of sellers.
The commission observed that the exemption had been claimed in a general and mechanical manner without demonstrating how disclosure of the specific information would adversely affect the competitive position of any third party.
"The mere description of information as commercially confidential or market-sensitive, without establishing the applicability of the statutory exemption, is not sufficient to deny access under the RTI Act," the commission said.
The applicant had also sought details about the introduction of a purported "link facility", including its policy objectives, beneficiaries, monitoring mechanism and audit trail, alleging that procurement links were being sent to selected sellers.
GeM said the query was not clear and informed the applicant that "there is no such link facility on the GeM portal".
It consequently did not provide responses to subsequent questions on whether such a facility could result in certain sellers repeatedly receiving opportunities to participate in similar bids.
In response to another query, GeM informed the applicant that 3,36,904 unique sellers had received orders on the platform till date. However, it said it did not maintain data on the number of unique sellers participating or the percentage of transactions concentrated among a limited number of repeated sellers, as the data was dynamic in nature.
On measures to prevent cartelisation, GeM said it examines complaints received through official channels and acts against firms involved in cartelisation in accordance with its General Terms and Conditions and Incident Management Policy.
"Buyers are also enabled to view network-related details of participating bidders to identify cartelisation and take appropriate action," GeM said.
The platform also said it provides system-enabled filters for MSME, women entrepreneurs and SC/ST seller categories to promote inclusive participation.
The commission also examined the applicant's request for year-wise procurement figures through GeM by the Indian Army, BSF, SSB, CRPF and other paramilitary forces.
GeM had initially invoked Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act, relating to information held in a fiduciary capacity, to deny the figures. During the hearing, its representatives claimed exemption under Section 8(1)(a).
The commission observed that GeM had not adequately explained the justification for the exemption and directed it to furnish a revised and categorical reply, identifying the relevant exemption clause and providing cogent reasons if any information was withheld.
According to figures furnished in the RTI reply, GeM recorded government procurement orders worth Rs 5.42 lakh crore in 2024-25. The second appeal was disposed of with these directions.
Source: PTI   By Rediff Money Desk, New Delhi
DISCLAIMER - This article is from a syndicated feed. The original source is responsible for accuracy, views & content ownership. Views expressed may not reflect those of rediff.com India Limited.

SC seeks Centre's response on plea to bring Collegium decisions under RTI : Bhavini Mishra

Business Standard: New Delhi: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
The petition seeks greater transparency in judicial appointments, including bringing Collegium decisions under the RTI Act and finalising the Memorandum of Procedure
The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Centre and its secretary general on a petition seeking greater transparency in judicial appointments, including bringing Collegium decisions within the ambit of the Right to Information (RTI) Act and finalising the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) governing the appointment of judges to constitutional courts.
A Bench of Justices M M Sundresh and P B Varale issued notice on a plea filed by NGO Lok Prahari.
The petition also sought directions to the Chief Justice of India (CJI), in his administrative capacity, to initiate the process of revising the MoP in accordance with the Supreme Court's 2015 judgment striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC).
During the hearing, Justice Sundresh initially questioned whether he should hear the matter, given his position as a member of the Supreme Court Collegium.
"Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of collegium," he observed.
Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for the petitioner, said he had no objection to the judge hearing the case, pointing out that several judges who might hear the petition would also be members of the Collegium.
"Many of your lordships will be members of collegium. That objection will never go away," Hegde submitted.
The judge subsequently agreed to issue notice, while observing that the petition could have been drafted better. The court permitted the petitioner to file an amended plea.
The petition contends that the existing MoP lacks adequate transparency and objective criteria for selecting judges, affecting the quality of appointments and the performance of constitutional courts.
It argues that a clearly defined selection framework is necessary to safeguard litigants' access to justice.
Lok Prahari has sought directions for the Centre's Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the MoP within a month of consulting the CJI. It has also urged that appointments be guided by the unanimous view of the Collegium, taking into account the principles laid down in the 2015 NJAC judgment.
The MoP was first framed in June 1999 following the Supreme Court's directions in the Second Judges case. It prescribes the process for appointments to the higher judiciary under the Collegium system.
The framework came under scrutiny after Parliament enacted the NJAC Act in 2015, seeking to replace the Collegium with a commission comprising members of the judiciary and the executive.
However, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court struck down the law on October 16, 2015, holding that it violated the independence of the judiciary.
Following the verdict, the court invited suggestions to improve the Collegium system and, in December 2015, entrusted the Centre with revising the MoP. Differences between the government and the judiciary, however, delayed its finalisation.
In March 2017, the Supreme Court rejected the Centre's proposal to give the government the power to reject candidates recommended for judicial appointments on grounds of national security. The court also did not accept the proposal for a permanent secretariat for the Collegium.
The delay prompted another round of judicial intervention in October 2017, when a Bench of Justices A K Goel and U U Lalit sought the Centre's response on the prolonged delay in finalising the MoP.
The order, however, was subsequently recalled by a Bench headed by then CJI Dipak Misra.
Justice P S Narasimha had recused himself from the present matter when it was first taken up on November 2, citing his earlier appearance as an additional solicitor general in a similar dispute concerning the MoP.

Two VACB wings exempted from RTI Act only to protect confidential information, Kerala HC told

Times of India: Kerala: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
The vigilance director has informed the high court that the recent govt notification exempting the T1 and T2 sections of the directorate of vigilance and anti-corruption bureau (VACB) from the purview of Right to Information Act aims only to protect confidential information, including source reports, surprise checks and personal files, and prevent premature disclosure that could derail investigations.
In an affidavit filed in response to PILs challenging the notification dated Oct 22, vigilance director Manoj Abraham stated that the exemption was strictly confined to sensitive intelligence and did not grant a blanket exemption to the agency. The petitioners alleged that the impugned notification effectively excludes information relating to vigilance inquiries, intelligence inputs and records concerning suspected corruption and misconduct in public administration from the statutory framework governing access to information.
Abraham stated that the VACB has 52 sections dealing with vigilance inquiries, criminal investigations and related administrative matters, of which T1 and T2 are two. The T2 section deals exclusively with sensitive information, including files relating to source reports and intelligence inputs, orders for surprise checks, confidential verifications and petitions. The T1 section also deals with sensitive information of the same nature, besides the annual confidential reports of the bureau’s ministerial and executive staff and the personal files of executive staff of the rank of inspector of police. Since information relating to the service matters of vigilance personnel is not sensitive, such records have been reassigned to the Establishment section, the affidavit stated.
The affidavit further contended that disclosing the existence of confidential verifications, particularly in disproportionate assets cases, would enable corrupt officials to destroy evidence and intimidate informants. It noted that Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act offers inadequate protection before a formal case is registered. Premature disclosure of the existence or contents of a source report, intelligence input, confidential verification or surprise check would alert the public servant concerned, enabling him to conceal or transfer assets, destroy or fabricate documents, and influence witnesses, particularly in disproportionate assets cases.
The VACB has urged the court not to interfere with the notification, asserting that the exemption is essential for effective anti-corruption administration.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Cost of Ahmedabad-Mumbai bullet train project nearly doubles to Rs 2 lakh crore: RTI

Deccan Herald: Ahmedabad: Wednesday, 18 November 2026.
The project has been delayed substantially over various issues, including compensation for land acquisition, among others.

Construction site on the Mumbai-Ahmedabad Bullet Train corridor, in Gujarat's Anand.Credit: PTI Photo

The National High Speed Rail Corporation Ltd (NHSRCL) has spent Rs 92,761 crore on the Ahmedabad-Mumbai high-speed rail corridor (MAHSR) as of March 2026, while the cost of the ambitious project has nearly doubled, an RTI response has revealed.
The revised estimated cost of MAHSR, popularly known as the bullet train project, has increased to Rs 2,02,797 crore, nearly double the initial estimate of Rs 1,08,000 crore. The 508-km corridor passes through Maharashtra, Gujarat, and the Union Territory of Dadra & Nagar Haveli.
The project has been delayed substantially over various issues, including compensation for land acquisition, among others.
In response to an RTI query filed by a DH reporter, the NHSRCL said the project was originally targeted for completion by 2023. However, the anticipated completion timeline "can be ascertained after award of all contract packages," the reply said in response to a question about a tentative timeline for completion of the project.
On query whether the proposed combination of Japanese track technology, non-Japanese signalling and India-built trains was part of the original project design, the response stated that "it was planned to start the operation using Japanese Shinkansen Rolling Stock." However, it has been decided to start operation using an indigenously developed trainset, it added.
Queries related to copies of correspondence between the government of India and Japan over reported disagreements over procuring signalling systems were denied, citing, "the sharing of these documents is restricted as covered under Non-Disclosure Agreement between both the governments."
On the question of delivery schedule for trains and their revised delivery schedule, the reply stated that "the dispatch of the first indigenous trainset from BEML Ltd is planned in February 2027. Subsequent trainsets shall follow."
NHSRCL refused to provide records of whether the Japanese government approved or objected to the use of India-manufactured trains, saying that such records can't be provided as per Section 9 (1) (f) of the RTI Act. This clause exempts the government from disclosing information received in confidence from a foreign government.

Naini Counters BRS Allegations With RTI Documents

Deccan Chronicle: Warangal: Wednesday, 18 November 2026.
MLA presents records on YSR Nagar lands and commercial building at Kazipet crossroads
Warangal West MLA Naini Rajender Reddy on Tuesday countered allegations over the YSR Nagar lands in Kazipet and a commercial building at the Kazipet crossroads by presenting documents obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
Addressing a press conference at Kazipet, Rajender Reddy displayed records from the revenue, Kakatiya Urban Development Authority (Kuda) and Greater Warangal Municipal Corporation (GWMC) departments.
Rajender Reddy said the YSR Nagar lands originally belonged to an Irani family and came under the Urban Land Ceiling Act, following which family members approached the High Court. He questioned how land recorded as ceiling-surplus in revenue records until 2018 was converted for Non-Agricultural Lands Assessment (NALA) use in 2019, during the previous BRS regime. He presented pahani records and other documents in support of his claims.
On the commercial building at Kazipet crossroads, Rajender Reddy sought an explanation from former Kuda chairman Marri Yadava Reddy over the conversion of residential land for commercial use in 2017. He also called for scrutiny of building permissions, setbacks and the occupancy certificate.
Referring to the controversy over huts at YSR Nagar, the MLA said poor residents should not face hardship and assured them of his support.
Rajender Reddy said he would stand by the hut dwellers despite the political criticism.
Rajender Reddy said the district collector had informed him that Section 144 was in force in the area. He cautioned landowners and others against taking the law into their own hands and said he would continue to present documents and facts in response to the political allegations.

RTI reply flags acute diagnostic and staffing deficits at Govt. Medical College Hospital, Kollam

The Hindu: Kollam: Wednesday, 18 November 2026.
Human Rights Protection Mission raises serious concerns regarding vacancies across various departments, availability of specialised care, operational status of medical equipment, and high rate of patient referrals to other hospitals
The Human Rights Protection Mission (HRPM) has urged the Keralam government to conduct a comprehensive inquiry into the medical facilities, staff availability, and diagnostic infrastructure at the Government Medical College Hospital, Kollam.
Citing documents obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the organisation flagged serious concerns regarding vacancies across various departments, the availability of specialised care, the operational status of medical equipment, and the high rate of patient referrals to other hospitals.
At a press meet here on Tuesday, representatives of the HRPM pointed out that patients arriving at a government medical college often a primary lifeline for ordinary and economically disadvantaged citizens should not face treatment delays or be forced to seek care elsewhere due to basic infrastructural and staffing deficits.
Patient referrals
According to the RTI disclosures, the Gynaecology department alone recorded 20,025 outpatient visits and 8,042 surgical or medical procedures in 2025, yet 156 patients from the same department had to be referred to the SAT Hospital in Thiruvananthapuram.
“Whether these referrals stemmed from a shortage of specialist doctors, inadequate facilities, or administrative lapses needs an official explanation. There is also the question about the availability and maintenance of critical diagnostic and endoscopic tools and advanced testing facilities to spare poor patients from financial strain and delayed diagnoses,” they said.
To address these gaps, the HRPM called upon senior Health department officials to inspect the institution, urgently fill vacant positions for doctors, nurses, and paramedical staff, and repair or replace defunct machinery purchased with public funds.
The organisation further demanded a time-bound development plan to upgrade beds, medicine supplies, and specialty departments in proportion to the patient load, alongside making the inspection findings public. “We plan to submit a formal memorandum detailing these RTI findings and public complaints to the Health Minister, top health and medical education officials, and college authorities,” they said.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Punjab RTI Order Exposes the Limits of Secrecy in Public Hospitals : By Ananya Sharma

Urban Acres: Chandigarh: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
A Punjab RTI order directing Civil Hospital Kharar to disclose a Medical Board opinion has brought a recurring governance problem into focus: how public institutions should protect third-party information without blocking access to official records needed to defend oneself in court. The State Information Commission’s decision does not determine the merits of the criminal case linked to the records. It instead establishes that the nature of a document, the institution that created it and the purpose for which it is sought can matter when authorities consider an exemption under the Right to Information Act.
The case arose from a dispute connected to an FIR and a cross daily diary report registered at Nayagaon police station in Mohali on August 30, 2025. A Mohali resident approached the senior medical officer of Civil Hospital, Kharar, seeking certified copies of the final opinion prepared by a Medical Board, the police letter that led to the Board’s constitution and communications issued by the hospital or the Board requiring his appearance.
The Medical Board comprised three senior medical officers and was constituted at the government hospital on a request from the police. According to the account before the Commission, the Board submitted its opinion to the investigating officer on January 29, 2026. The appellant argued that the records were directly connected with criminal proceedings pending before a competent court and were essential to his defence.
The hospital authorities had earlier resisted disclosure on the ground that the information concerned a third party. That objection reflected a legitimate tension within the RTI framework. Public records can contain personal, medical or otherwise sensitive information relating to people who are not applicants. At the same time, a blanket refusal can prevent a person from obtaining documents that may be relevant to legal proceedings, particularly when those documents were generated by public officials in the course of their duties.
The Commission’s order turned on this distinction. It noted that the Medical Board had been constituted by a government hospital after receiving a police communication and that its opinion had been prepared by government medical officers as part of their official work. The Commission also considered the appellant’s stated requirement for the documents in order to defend himself in the pending criminal proceedings.
During the hearing, a medical officer appeared on behalf of the respondents and produced the complete official record in a sealed envelope, complying with the Commission’s earlier directions. After hearing the parties and examining the records, the Commission directed that the information sought in the RTI application be supplied. The sealed envelope was subsequently opened and the documents were provided to the appellant during the hearing.
This sequence is important because it shows that the dispute was not resolved simply by treating the information as either wholly private or wholly public. The records were examined in the context of the request, the institution that generated them and the stated legal purpose for which they were required. The Commission’s reasoning, as reported, places emphasis on the records’ official character and their connection with an ongoing criminal proceeding.
The order also draws attention to the role of government hospitals beyond routine treatment. Civil Hospital Kharar became part of a chain involving the police, medical officers, the RTI mechanism and the court process. Its doctors were not acting only as healthcare providers in the ordinary sense. They were also performing an institutional function through a Medical Board constituted after a police request.
That institutional position creates accountability obligations. When a document is prepared by public employees in a public facility and transmitted to an investigating officer, questions about its creation, contents and handling can affect the rights of people involved in a case. The Commission did not state that every medical record must be disclosed to every applicant. Its decision was tied to the circumstances presented before it, including the appellant’s demonstrated requirement for the documents in his defence.
The Commission relied on the Supreme Court’s 2011 judgment in The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India versus Shaunak H Satya. As described in the report, that judgment explained that the RTI Act seeks to harmonise transparency and accountability with the protection of other legitimate interests. That principle is central to the Kharar dispute. RTI administration is not only about expanding disclosure; it is also about applying exemptions in a manner that recognises competing rights and interests.
The order therefore has a significance beyond the individual records. It illustrates how public authorities can face difficulty when an RTI request involves information about another person but is also connected with the applicant’s legal rights. The initial response from the hospital treated the third-party aspect as a reason for withholding the material. The Commission’s eventual decision required a closer examination of the document’s official source and the purpose for which it was sought.
The case also demonstrates the importance of documentary custody. The respondents produced the complete record in a sealed envelope before the Commission. This allowed the Bench to examine the documents rather than decide the dispute only on a general description of their contents. The record included the final Medical Board opinion, the police communication that initiated the process and hospital or Board communications concerning the appellant’s appearance.
For public institutions, the practical issue is not merely whether a file exists. It is how the file is classified, who holds it, whether it contains information relating to more than one person and whether the requested material has a direct bearing on another legal process. The Kharar order indicates that these questions may have to be assessed together rather than through a single broad objection.
The decision also preserves the separation between information disclosure and adjudication of the underlying dispute. The Commission expressly clarified that it was not commenting on the merits of the criminal proceedings, the correctness of the Medical Board’s opinion or the innocence or guilt of any person. Those matters remained within the jurisdiction of the competent court.
This limitation is significant. Access to a document does not amount to a finding that the document is accurate, conclusive or favourable to the person who obtains it. Nor does an RTI order replace the evidentiary process before a court. The Commission’s role in this case was to decide whether the requested information should be disclosed under the circumstances placed before it.
That separation can help prevent two common misunderstandings about RTI disputes. First, disclosure is not the same as endorsement of the contents of a record. Second, an exemption dispute does not itself decide the underlying criminal allegation. The Commission’s order dealt with access to information, while the court proceedings will determine the legal issues arising from the FIR and cross daily diary report.
The case also underlines the importance of the second-appeal mechanism in the RTI system. The applicant had first sought information from the Civil Hospital, Kharar, and later pursued a second appeal before the State Information Commission after the information was not supplied. The Commission’s intervention created a forum where the competing claims could be examined and where the original records could be produced for scrutiny.
At the same time, the reported order does not establish how frequently similar requests are made to government hospitals, how long the earlier refusal lasted or whether the Commission has issued broader procedural directions to hospitals across Punjab. Those questions are not answered in the supplied material. The decision should therefore be read as an order based on the particular facts before the Commission, not as a universal ruling that all medical information connected to criminal cases must be released.
The larger urban governance question is how public institutions manage records that sit at the intersection of service delivery, policing, medical assessment and legal process. Government hospitals are often among the most visible points of contact between residents and the state. Their administrative records can influence investigations and court proceedings, while their handling of information affects public confidence in institutional accountability.
The Punjab case confirms that the existence of third-party information cannot, in every circumstance, end the inquiry. Authorities must also consider whether the material was created through an official process and whether the applicant has shown a specific and legally relevant need for access. It leaves intact the protection of legitimate privacy and the jurisdiction of the courts over the criminal case.
The next stage is not a further finding by the Information Commission on guilt or responsibility. It is the use of the disclosed documents, if relevant, within the pending proceedings before the competent court. The order’s immediate outcome is narrower but important: records created by a government hospital for a police-linked Medical Board process were supplied after the Commission found that withholding them could adversely affect the appellant’s ability to present material in his defence.

Lokpal withdrew jt secretary recruitment ad after whistleblower Sanjiv Chaturvedi application: RTI

Times of India: Dehradun: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Lokpal of India withdrew its recruitment process for the post of joint secretary on Aug 17, citing “administrative reasons”, nearly four months after advertising the vacancy and receiving an application from Uttarakhand cadre Indian Forest Service officer and whistleblower Sanjiv Chaturvedi, an RTI response filed by Dehradun-based activist Bhupendra Chanda has revealed. The RTI reply said that the anti-corruption ombudsman had cancelled the exercise without explaining the decision.
Lokpal issued the vacancy circular on April 27, inviting applications for the post. Chaturvedi applied, and Uttarakhand govt forwarded his application on June 13, conveying its no-objection and consent for his deputation. However, Lokpal withdrew the circular on Aug 17, stating that no further action would be taken on applications received under it.
The cancellation marked another setback in Chaturvedi’s efforts to secure a deputation to Lokpal, which began in Dec 2019. On Dec 23 that year, Uttarakhand govt forwarded his request to the Union ministry of environment, forest and climate change (MoEF&CC) with its consent. The ministry sought a copy of the vacancy advertisement on Feb 5, 2020, but took no substantive action for nearly two and a half years, prompting Chaturvedi to approach Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT).
During the proceedings, CAT asked Centre to show “magnanimity and openness” while considering his request. On Sept 1, 2022, it directed the secretary of MoEF&CC to decide the matter within eight weeks in consultation with the department of personnel and training (DoPT).
However, the ministry returned his application through an order dated Oct 3, 2022, signed by a director-rank officer rather than the secretary. It said the request “did not accompany any vacancy circular” and cited DoPT instructions issued on Dec 12, 2013, which stated that applications not submitted against an advertised vacancy “should not be forwarded”. The ministry also referred to section 10 of the Lokpal Act, which empowers the Lokpal chairperson to appoint the institution’s staff.
The April 27 circular appeared to address the procedural objection raised in 2022, as Chaturvedi had applied for an advertised vacancy with Uttarakhand govt’s consent. Yet, the exercise was cancelled. The RTI response did not establish whether Chaturvedi’s application influenced the withdrawal decision.
Meanwhile, Centre directly appointed another officer as joint secretary in Lokpal in July 2026, without following the vacancy circular route. The appointment order reportedly included a relaxation of the cooling-off period requirement for the officer.

Information Commission resumes RTI complaint hearings after nearly two years

Dhaka Tribune: Dhaka: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
The Information Commission Bangladesh has resumed hearing complaints filed under the Right to Information (RTI) Act after nearly two years.
The Commission held hearings on five complaints on Monday, disposing of three of them and fixing dates for further hearings on the remaining two.
Chief Information Commissioner Prof Dr Nahreen Islam Khan, along with Information Commissioners S A M Mahfuzur Rahman and Khan Mohammad Abul Hossain, conducted the hearings.
With the Commission remaining non-functional for an extended period, a total of 917 complaints were filed over the past two years. The government reconstituted the Information Commission on October 17.
After assuming office, the newly constituted Commission adopted a 100-day action plan, prioritizing the disposal of pending complaints. As part of the initiative, it is working to expedite the hearing and resolution process.
The complaints heard on Monday concerned the non-disclosure of information relating to recruitment by various public and private institutions, land ownership and income-expenditure accounts of institutions, development projects and allocations of local government bodies, reasons for cancellation of appointment letters, recruitment examination answer scripts, and the leasing of government property.

Punjab Information Commission issues bailable warrants against Aero City SHO in RTI case :Barinderjit Saluja

Times of India: Chandigarh: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
The Punjab Information Commission has ordered the issuance of bailable warrants against the SHO of Bakarpur-Aero City police station in connection with a Right to Information (RTI) case, directing him to appear before the Commission with relevant records and evidence.
In an order dated Nov 5, chief information commissioner Inderpal Singh directed that bailable warrants be issued against the public information officer (PIO)/SHO of the police station. A copy of the order was also sent to the SSP, Mohali, for execution of the warrants.
The PIO has also been given an opportunity to submit a written reply and appear for a personal hearing under relevant sections of the RTI Act before any penalty is imposed.
The commission cautioned that if the PIO neither submits a written reply nor appears for the hearing on the next date, it would be presumed that he has nothing further to state, and the proceedings would continue ex parte.
The matter has been listed for Dec 17, 2026, at 11.30am in Chandigarh.

Tail-end farmers of PAP Main Canal approach Appellate Authority, resent denial of details about Apex Committee sought through RTI query

The Hindu: Tiruppur: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Not satisfied by ‘evasive’ replies to their query on existence of Apex Committee under the RTI Act by the Water Resources Department, farmers in the tail-end of PAP Main Canal have gone for first appeal under Section 19(1) of the Act. In a representation to the Appellate Authority Officer and joint Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, P. Velusamy, on behalf of the farmers, had sought information on the constitution of the Apex Committee.
The stand taken by the Public Information Officer (PIO) that the information sought extensive/ voluminous and invoked Section 7(9) of the RTI Act, prompted the farmers to go on appeal. The PIO’s reply, Mr. Velusamy said, was ‘incomplete, evasive and legally unsustainable’, and questioned the rationale behind invocation of Section 7(9) of the RTI Act (to deny the details), which is applicable only in situations where the information would disproportionately divert the resources of public authority, or be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record.
The RTI application, Mr. Velusamy pointed out, had asked for identifiable documents, including GO/ notification on constitution of the Apex Committee; appointment/nomination order of the Chairman, present list of members; term/tenure of Chairman and members, official address and contact details; meeting details and minutes; and records establishing the constitution of the Committee after April 21, 2026. The WRD’s reply to an earlier RTI query on this date stated that the Apex Committee has not been constituted, and that its meetings had not taken place during the preceding three years.
The appeal also sought information on the documents/ instructions on the basis of which the learned Special Government Pleader represented before the High Court that the Apex Committee was already in existence and functioning; records relating to the receipt and implementation of the High Court order; action taken on the representation dated March 10, 2026; and relevant government orders, rules and proceedings governing the Apex Committee.
Transparency in these matters is directly connected with public accountability, lawful administration and the interests of thousands of registered ayacutdars dependent upon PAP system, Mr. Velusamy said, requesting the First Appellate Authority to furnish complete information.

Monday, November 16, 2026

RTI Data, Bride 18, groom 19: How a late-night raid stopped a Haryana child marriage - Written by: Sukhbir Siwach

Indian Express: Haryana: Monday, 16 November 2026.
RTI data from the Haryana Women and Child Development Department reveals 4,284 child marriage complaints across the state over the past decade, with Panipat (456), Sirsa (444), and Fatehabad (423) recording the highest numbers.

A late-night intervention stopped a proposed child marriage in Jind after officials found the 19-year-old groom was below the legal marriage age (Express photo/Special arrangement).

A decorated tent had been erected, around 100 wedding guests and members of the procession were having the feast, and pre-wedding rituals were underway just before the pheras (the ceremonial rounds around the sacred fire) when a joint team of officials and activists stepped in to halt a child marriage midway during a late-night intervention in Haryana’s Jind district last month.
The Sonipat unit of Mission to the Desperate and Destitute of India (MDD of India), an associate organisation of Just Rights for Children (JRC) in Haryana, had initially received confidential information that a wedding procession was scheduled to travel from a village in Sonipat district to a village in Jind district.
A team comprising officials from the administrations of Jind and Sonipat districts, police personnel, the Child Marriage Prohibition Officer, and members of MDD of India reached the groom’s village in Sonipat district, only to find the procession had already left for Jind. Rushing to the bride’s home in a village in Jind district, they arrived just in time to stop the ceremony.
The officials immediately halted the rituals and sought the birth certificates of the bride and groom to verify their ages. The bride’s family promptly produced her birth certificate, which established that she was 18 years and five days old. However, the groom’s family delayed producing his documents for nearly two hours. Following firm intervention by the team, his birth certificate was finally produced, revealing that he was only 19 years old.
Under the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, the minimum legal age for marriage is 18 years for women and 21 years for men. Since the groom was below the legally prescribed age, the marriage could not proceed.
Meanwhile, the bride’s family alleged that the groom’s family had misled them about his age and refused to go ahead with the marriage. Both families returned the dowry articles, jewellery and other belongings to each other at the spot, and the wedding procession subsequently returned without the bride.
According to Narendra Sharma, Jind district coordinator of MDD of India, who has been actively associated with efforts to prevent child marriages and promote children’s rights, as many as five suspected child marriage cases had been reported from different villages of Jind district within a week in October.
Following the vigilance of the district child marriage prohibition officer and activists associated with JRC, three marriages were stopped before the ceremonies could take place, while investigations are underway in the remaining two cases where the marriages had already been solemnised.
In another incident on October 16, a team led by Ravi Lohan, Assistant District Child Marriage Prohibition Officer in Jind, stopped the proposed marriages of two cousins in a village in the district. Both wedding processions had arrived from a village in Hisar district, and document verification revealed that both brides and one of the grooms were minors.
In a suspected child marriage case reported on October 17, the authorities could not prevent the marriage as the information reached them after the wedding ceremonies had been completed. The wedding procession, which had arrived from a village in Charkhi Dadri district, had already completed the rituals and returned before the intervention team reached the spot.
Officials later contacted the families by phone, arranged for the bride and groom to be called back while they were still on their way, and handed the bride over to her family while the district administration investigates the matter to verify her age.
Surinder Singh Maan, chief executive officer of MDD of India, said the wedding season had begun in Haryana and that the organisation’s teams would work closely with the district administrations to maintain strict vigilance against child marriages across 21 districts of the state.
Panipat, Sirsa and Fatehabad top complaint tally
Data obtained by Narendra Sharma under the Right to Information (RTI) Act from the Haryana Women and Child Development Department shows that Panipat, Sirsa and Fatehabad have recorded the highest number of child marriage complaints in Haryana over the past decade, with a total of 4,284 complaints reported across the state’s 22 districts between 2015-16 and 2024-25. In most of the reported cases, child marriages were prevented following timely intervention by the authorities and NGOs.
Panipat topped the list with 456 complaints during the period, followed by Sirsa with 444 complaints, while neighbouring Fatehabad recorded 423 and Jind district reported 324 complaints. Asked about the possible reasons behind the comparatively high number of complaints in certain areas, a senior official of the Haryana Women and Child Development Department said that the practice might be prevalent in some specific communities and among migrant families in the districts concerned.
Department Director Priyanka Soni stated, “Social factors remain the primary drivers of child marriage. In relatively developed areas and communities, families tend to delay their children’s marriages until they are settled in life. We have been undertaking awareness campaigns to prevent child marriages and address the social factors contributing to the practice.”
She added that Haryana has 13 District Protection-cum-Prohibition Officers entrusted with preventing child marriages at the district level and ensuring the protection, care and welfare of affected children.
Meanwhile, Bhuwan Ribhu, founder of Just Rights for Children (JRC), stated that the organisation aims to eradicate the social evils of child marriage and forced marriage from India by 2030. Highlighting that over 250 civil society organisations associated with JRC are actively working on the ground across all 782 districts of the country, he emphasised that JRC would play a proactive and leading role in supporting and strengthening the Government of India’s ‘Bal Vivah Mukt Bharat’ (Child Marriage-Free India) campaign.
District-wise Child Marriage Complaints in Haryana (2015-16 to 2024-25)
Ambala: 127
Bhiwani: 129
Charkhi Dadri: 16
Faridabad: 135
Fatehabad: 423
Gurgaon: 50
Hisar: 283
Jhajjar: 65
Jind: 324
Kaithal: 214
Karnal: 269
Kurukshetra: 126
Mahendragarh: 127
Mewat: 377
Palwal: 151
Panipat: 456
Panchkula: 31
Rewari: 79
Rohtak: 148
Sirsa: 444
Sonipat: 188
Yamunanagar: 122
Total: 4,284
Source: Haryana Women and Child Development Department
Period: 2015-16 to 2024-25

RTI : BMC Acted Against Only 15.6% of Illegal Construction Complaints Over 10 Years

Clarion India: Mumbai: Monday, 16 November 2026.
An RTI reply shows that the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation received 98,689 original complaints over a decade, but carried out demolition action in only 13,211 cases
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) took demolition action in only 13,211 cases out of 98,689 original complaints about illegal constructions received over the past 10 years, according to information obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
The figures, obtained by RTI activist Shakeel Ahmed Sheikh, raise questions about the municipal body’s handling of complaints against unauthorised constructions and the functioning of its online Real Estate Tracking Management System (RETMS), which was introduced to receive complaints and facilitate action against such structures.
According to the information supplied by the BMC, it received a total of 214,917 complaints during the 10 years. Of these, 116,229 were repeat complaints, while the number of original complaints was recorded as 98,689.
Demolition action was carried out in 13,211 cases, amounting to approximately 15.6 per cent of the original complaints.
The BMC’s figures also provide details of notices issued and the subsequent stages of action. A total of 60,332 notices were prepared against the original complaints, of which 57,521 were issued. The civic body also issued 31,486 show-cause notices.
Demolition was considered necessary in 29,916 cases. The arrangements for demolition were reported to be pending in 15,318 cases, while arrangements had been made in 1,387 cases. Actual demolition action was carried out in 13,211 cases.
The figures raise questions about the gap between cases in which demolition was considered necessary and those in which the civic body actually acted. The RTI activist has called for the BMC to make the present status of all pending cases public and explain the action being taken in each of them.
The ward-wise figures also show considerable differences in the number of complaints and demolition action.
L Ward recorded the highest number of complaints, with 30,935 cases. However, demolition action was taken in only 637 cases.
K East Ward received 24,064 complaints, of which 1,325 resulted in demolition action. M East Ward recorded 14,510 complaints, but action was taken in just 159 cases. P South Ward received 14,424 complaints, with demolition action reported in 1,932 cases.
The figures for L Ward are particularly striking: despite having the highest number of complaints, the number of demolitions remained relatively low.
Sheikh questioned the BMC’s handling of illegal constructions and the gap between notices and actual enforcement.
“The BMC’s Building and Factory Department has been taking action against illegal constructions for a long time. Crores of rupees are spent every year, yet illegal constructions continue to receive protection?” he asked.
He said more than 15,000 notices were issued annually, but the rate of actual demolition remained very low.
“Why is actual action not taken after notices are issued? What disciplinary action has been taken against officials who fail to act? How many times have responsible officers protecting illegal constructions been suspended? The public should be given answers to these questions,” Sheikh said.
He has written to Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Municipal Commissioner Ashwini Bhide, urging them to initiate demolition action against pending illegal constructions without further delay.
He has also demanded the suspension of officials and employees found responsible and strict action against them.
The RTI figures come at a time when the Maharashtra government has spoken of its ambition to transform Mumbai into a city comparable to Shanghai. The findings raise questions about the BMC’s enforcement of building regulations and its ability to address complaints of unauthorised construction across the city.