Mumbai Mirror: Mumbai: Saturday, 21 November 2026.
From RTI applications and social media campaigns to protests and court battles, three activists and an environmentalist show how citizens can turn complaints into accountability
Mumbai has more than 20 million people, but getting its administration to listen can feel like an endless struggle. A bridge closure paralyses traffic; a neglected space beneath a flyover takes three years of campaigning to become a garden; an environmental complaint leads to a 15-year court battle. Even obtaining information through an RTI application can become a prolonged exercise.
Broken roads, delayed projects, disappearing green spaces and illegal dumping leave residents asking: Who is responsible, where should they complain and what does it take to get action? Civic engagement often begins with reporting a pothole or writing to the municipal corporation. When nothing happens, most give up. A few persist.
That was the focus of an October 28 roundtable at Mumbai Mirror, titled ‘From Civic Complaints to Civic Action: Making the System Listen’. It brought together four activists who have spent years questioning authorities, mobilising residents and pursuing civic and environmental issues.
RTI activist Anil Galgali spoke about using public records to demand accountability. Dhaval Shah, co-founder of the Lokhandwala Oshiwara Citizens Association (LOCA), described how residents organised around infrastructure issues, including the Gokhale Bridge closure. Nikhil Desai, associated with Matunga’s Advanced Locality Management movement, shared how residents reclaimed neglected public spaces. Stalin Dayanand, director of environmental NGO Vanashakti, spoke about taking environmental disputes to court.
Their experiences showed how citizens are forced to monitor work government departments should do, but also offered practical lessons on how to press officials for action.
RTI: Can information force accountability?
For Anil Galgali, the Right to Information Act remains one of the most powerful tools available to ordinary citizens. Two decades after the law came into force, however, he believes delays have weakened its impact.
Galgali called RTI India’s “second freedom”, giving citizens the right to seek official records without explaining why. Authorities generally have 30 days to respond, but appeals can take years, he said.
“Every government wants that people don’t ask questions in RTI,” he said, criticising political parties for supporting transparency in opposition but becoming less enthusiastic about it when in power.
Galgali said applicants often weaken their requests by asking broad questions or seeking explanations instead of specific records.
“RTI is only a document,” he said. His advice: keep each application focused on one subject and one department. If the relevant records are difficult to identify, applicants can seek permission to inspect the files and select the documents they need.
He also cited Section 4, which requires authorities to proactively disclose specified information. Citizens should not have to repeatedly seek records that should be online. Galgali said follow-ups helped improve access to building-related records on the BMC’s website.
RTI, however, should not be the first response to every civic problem. When he recently found a parking plot in Dadar lying unused, he photographed it and posted the issue on X, tagging the relevant municipal ward. He also sent the post to senior civic officials.
When a problem is visible, he argued, citizens should seek action rather than another document. RTI records, however, can help pursue accountability.
Galgali cited a case involving an Air India computer procurement worth about Rs 250 crore. He said documents obtained through RTI helped him approach the Central Vigilance Commission, after which the complaint led to a CBI investigation.
“You need an authentic document,” he said.
Gokhale Bridge: Making officials keep their promises
For residents of Andheri, the closure of Gokhale Bridge disrupted traffic across a roughly six-kilometre stretch, affecting commuters, businesses and access to the airport.
Dhaval Shah recalled that officials initially indicated the bridge would reopen within six months. Residents recorded a public meeting with officials and elected representatives so they could refer to the assurances later.
“We wanted to hear every single thing and note it down for future reference,” he said.
The first phase opened after nearly two years and about seven missed deadlines, Shah said. A WhatsApp group grew to more than 1,000 members within a week. Residents submitted petitions, approached officials and kept the issue alive on social media. Shah credited sustained media coverage with helping the campaign.
Shah urged residents not to feel embarrassed about repeatedly seeking answers.
“Over the years we have become shameless. And I advise others to do so too. Only then can you demand and get response and action from the system,” he said.
LOCA records meetings and circulates minutes. Shah recalled an elected representative later trying to reinterpret an assurance that the bridge would reopen in May. Written commitments make it harder for officials to change their promises.
Shah cited a long-pending fire station reservation for Lokhandwala-Versova, saying the nearest station is about six kilometres away despite repeated fires. “Unless and until there is an episode, people don’t take interest in it,” he said.
For Shah, the lesson from Gokhale Bridge is that residents must organise before a crisis, stay involved after it and keep asking officials to honour their commitments.
From complaints to solutions: Three years to build a garden
In Matunga, residents spent three years trying to turn a neglected space beneath a flyover into a public garden and walkway.
Nikhil Desai said the campaign began after taxis started gathering beneath the flyover. Drivers wanted space to park and rest, while residents feared the area would become permanently occupied.
Desai persuaded the local ward office to temporarily block vehicle access. Residents then offered to beautify the space at their own cost and hand it over to the civic body for maintenance. But they discovered that the land belonged to the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), not the BMC.
MMRDA asked for a formal proposal. Residents from around 80 buildings suggested facilities including badminton and basketball courts. An architect prepared a plan estimated to cost more than Rs 4 crore. Desai recalled being asked to show that residents could raise around Rs 2 crore.
“We didn’t have even 40 rupees at the time,” he said.
The land was subsequently transferred to the BMC, forcing residents to start discussions again. Desai eventually approached the municipal commissioner with a different argument: why should citizens raise crores to develop a public space when the municipal garden department had funds for such work?
The administration agreed to examine the proposal. The space was eventually developed into a garden with a 700-metre walkway. Desai also recalled approaching then MP Rahul Shewale to secure a wider path for pedestrians.
Why do ward offices not respond?
“If you have a solution, in fact they do listen at higher levels. Ward level unfortunately has become non-answerable,” Desai said.
He cited a dispute over a proposed booth on the footpath outside Khalsa College in Matunga. Desai argued that the structure would obstruct students and pedestrians. After the ward office failed to resolve the issue, he repeatedly raised it at the municipal commissioner’s public grievance meetings, taking photographs, documents and a letter signed by around 200 people.
The commissioner eventually directed that the booth be removed and an alternative location considered, according to Desai.
He questioned why a citizen should have to approach the municipal commissioner to resolve a basic footpath complaint. The absence of an effective, time-bound citizens’ charter, he said, allows departments to delay responses without consequence.
“Any work is given, within how much time period you will give the answer and solve that thing,” he said.
Desai also criticised corruption, arguing that rules and penalties lose their value when officials find ways around them. Unless corruption is addressed, he said, lasting civic improvements will remain difficult.
Environmental battles: 15 years and counting
While Galgali uses information, Shah relies on resident mobilisation and Desai works through civic departments, environmentalist Stalin Dayanand has taken several disputes to court.
The Vanashakti director said environmental complaints can take years to resolve, even when violations are documented.
“For the state or the system to respond, you have to be very persistent. You can’t hide and just have a one-off message or a letter and expect things to move,” he said.
Stalin recalled confronting the dumping of nearly 500 truckloads of mud on a wetland in Wadala during the lockdown, after authorities allegedly failed to act. He pursued the matter for five years, including through the National Green Tribunal. However, the person responsible for the dumping was eventually fined just Rs 500, he said. Stalin argued that such nominal penalties do little to deter environmental violations.
He said some Wadala residents who complained about ready-mix concrete plants and air quality were intimidated at home after filing complaints and RTI applications.
“Intimidation, that happens. So, you have to be ready for that,” he warned. His advice was to build support rather than take on powerful interests alone. Even five or ten people standing together can make a difference, he said.
Stalin was also sceptical about involving politicians in environmental disputes, alleging that political interests can contribute to environmental damage. He recommended a sequence of filing a complaint, using RTI to seek records of action taken, following up and turning to legal remedies if the administration fails to respond. Vanashakti generally allows about six months of follow-up before considering litigation, he said.
The Ulhas river case
Stalin cited the Ulhas river pollution case as an example of what sustained legal action can achieve. He said proceedings in the Supreme Court resulted in the government paying Rs 100 crore over pollution in the river.
Municipal bodies discharging untreated sewage were subsequently required to establish treatment infrastructure, although he said Kalyan remained an exception at the time of the discussion.
“It took eight years for that,” he said. The wider effort to secure compliance from industries had continued for about 15 years.
He also cited the Sawantwadi-Dodamarg wildlife corridor, where 38 mining proposals threatened an ecologically sensitive area. He said the court cancelled a public hearing for one proposal despite restrictions on tree felling.
Stalin said the area received protection through a court decision in 2025, after a struggle lasting around 15 years. The case, he argued, showed that a legal order does not always end a dispute; authorities may still need to be pushed to comply.
Development versus conservation
Stalin questioned projects that, in his view, treat environmental damage as an unavoidable cost of development. He raised concerns about a proposed educational complex in the Film City area and questioned why alternative sites were not considered before forest land was affected.
“Is it a Tree Authority for preserving trees or for clearing trees?” he asked, arguing that saplings elsewhere cannot replace a mature forest.
“None of us say that India should not progress. You can save it and do it,” he said. The choice, he argued, should not be between development and the environment.
Kanjurmarg: The need for scrutiny
The Kanjurmarg dumping ground was another example of the gap between official assurances and public scrutiny. Stalin questioned the transparency of its operations and cited satellite-based reporting on methane emissions.
“If it is scientific, you will take students there. You will allow researchers to go and see how it is done. You will allow media to go in there,” he said, arguing that restricted access makes independent scrutiny difficult.
He also spoke about delays in litigation and the difficulty of enforcing favourable court orders. If authorities fail to comply, he said, citizens may have to file contempt proceedings.
“You have to hang in there and keep fighting. Persistence is the key,” he said.
Who gets a say in Mumbai’s development?
The discussion highlighted how little opportunity residents have to question major projects before decisions are made.
Shah said residents are often informed after key decisions have been made. He called for public meetings on infrastructure projects worth even Rs 200 crore.
Citing the Mrinaltai Gore flyover, he questioned differences between proposed and completed alignments, as well as defects in newly built roads and flyovers.
Stalin said Detailed Project Reports, environmental clearances and other project documents should be readily available. He recalled that obtaining Mumbai Metro 3’s Detailed Project Report had initially involved a demand for around Rs 80,000, before the documents were eventually made available online.
But residents also need to use the opportunities available to them. Shah recalled attending a public hearing on tree cutting at which only six people turned up, including him and a friend.
Residents complain that decisions are made without their consent, he said, but often skip hearings where they can object.
Redevelopment without infrastructure
Shah warned that redevelopment in Mumbai’s suburbs is outpacing improvements to basic infrastructure.
In Andheri, he said, buildings that once had four to seven floors are being replaced by towers of 30 to 35 floors. Roads, drainage, water supply and emergency services have not necessarily expanded at the same rate.
“You need an audit of the existing infrastructure and the carrying capacity of that locality,” he said.
He called for independent assessments before redevelopment permissions are granted, to establish how much additional population and traffic an area can support. LOCA has also pushed for road setbacks to make space for wider roads and utilities.
The question is whether Mumbai is planning for the people who will occupy these towers.
Can social media turn complaints into action?
Posting photographs, tagging the BMC and hoping a complaint goes viral has become a common response to civic problems.
Social media helps residents reach officials and mobilise support, but cannot replace follow-up.
Shah encouraged residents to join existing citizens’ associations or form neighbourhood groups. LOCA’s social media presence, which had about 32,000 followers at the time of the discussion, helps bring attention to issues that individual residents may struggle to raise.
Galgali recommended X for reporting visible civic problems, while Shah suggested tagging established residents’ groups to widen a complaint’s reach.
But the Gokhale Bridge campaign showed that online pressure must be backed by meetings, petitions, letters and direct engagement with officials. A viral post attracts attention; sustained follow-up is what keeps a department accountable.
The activists also cited public apathy and divisions within housing societies. Galgali criticised societies seeking favours such as benches and bins from politicians instead of demanding transparent use of public funds. Shah said party loyalties can weaken campaigns.
Stalin said collective action also protects activists from intimidation: “When you are alone, you are at great risk of being targeted.”
Is civic activism accessible to everyone?
RTI applications, repeated ward visits, public hearings and court cases require resources many Mumbaikars do not have. Residents’ groups can help, but the burden cannot rest on volunteers. Citizens should not need legal expertise, political connections or thousands of social media followers to secure a basic service.
Where should a Mumbaikar begin?
For potholes, blocked drains and encroached footpaths, the panelists offered practical starting points.
Galgali recommended the BMC’s 1916 helpline and X. Complaints directed to the relevant municipal ward can sometimes get a quicker response on social media, he said. For road-related problems, residents can approach the ward’s roads department or the BMC’s roads department. If the issue remains unresolved, RTI can be used to seek records of repairs, contractors, expenditure and action taken.
Shah suggested tagging established residents’ associations to bring wider attention to individual complaints.
For environmental violations, including mangrove destruction and dumping, Stalin advised documenting the incident and reporting it to the Forest Department or the relevant mangrove protection authorities. He also referred to the Mangrove Suraksha app and urged residents to keep written records of complaints. He cautioned that complainants’ personal details may be disclosed to those named in complaints, and suggested that people concerned about retaliation avoid publicly revealing their identity.
The activists also stressed the importance of protecting open spaces before they are occupied or their use is changed. Galgali cited campaigns to reopen Gandhi Maidan in Kurla and make a garden in Chandivali accessible. Shah recalled efforts to restore Lokhandwala Lake, including removing invasive vegetation and preventing idol immersion in the waterbody. A separate temporary immersion facility now accommodates around 3,000 idols each year, he said.
The fight for accountability
The four activists outlined different routes to civic action: official records, collective pressure, practical proposals and, when necessary, litigation.
Each approach has limits: RTI appeals are delayed, online campaigns lose momentum, departments pass responsibility and court orders can be difficult to enforce.
Citizens also have a role to play. Poor attendance at public hearings, indifference to redevelopment plans and the abandonment of complaints after an initial response weaken accountability. But that does not absolve the administration of its responsibility to provide basic services.
Why should residents spend three years securing a public garden, mobilise thousands to demand the reopening of a bridge or fight environmental cases for 15 years before institutions perform their duties?
Mumbai’s activists have shown that the system can be made to respond. What remains uncertain is whether it will do so without being forced.
The right to vote gives Mumbaikars a say in who governs them; the right to question and demand answers shapes the years between elections. Mumbai belongs to those who live in it as much as to those who govern it.
From RTI applications and social media campaigns to protests and court battles, three activists and an environmentalist show how citizens can turn complaints into accountability
Mumbai has more than 20 million people, but getting its administration to listen can feel like an endless struggle. A bridge closure paralyses traffic; a neglected space beneath a flyover takes three years of campaigning to become a garden; an environmental complaint leads to a 15-year court battle. Even obtaining information through an RTI application can become a prolonged exercise.
Broken roads, delayed projects, disappearing green spaces and illegal dumping leave residents asking: Who is responsible, where should they complain and what does it take to get action? Civic engagement often begins with reporting a pothole or writing to the municipal corporation. When nothing happens, most give up. A few persist.
That was the focus of an October 28 roundtable at Mumbai Mirror, titled ‘From Civic Complaints to Civic Action: Making the System Listen’. It brought together four activists who have spent years questioning authorities, mobilising residents and pursuing civic and environmental issues.
RTI activist Anil Galgali spoke about using public records to demand accountability. Dhaval Shah, co-founder of the Lokhandwala Oshiwara Citizens Association (LOCA), described how residents organised around infrastructure issues, including the Gokhale Bridge closure. Nikhil Desai, associated with Matunga’s Advanced Locality Management movement, shared how residents reclaimed neglected public spaces. Stalin Dayanand, director of environmental NGO Vanashakti, spoke about taking environmental disputes to court.
Their experiences showed how citizens are forced to monitor work government departments should do, but also offered practical lessons on how to press officials for action.
RTI: Can information force accountability?
For Anil Galgali, the Right to Information Act remains one of the most powerful tools available to ordinary citizens. Two decades after the law came into force, however, he believes delays have weakened its impact.
Galgali called RTI India’s “second freedom”, giving citizens the right to seek official records without explaining why. Authorities generally have 30 days to respond, but appeals can take years, he said.
“Every government wants that people don’t ask questions in RTI,” he said, criticising political parties for supporting transparency in opposition but becoming less enthusiastic about it when in power.
Galgali said applicants often weaken their requests by asking broad questions or seeking explanations instead of specific records.
“RTI is only a document,” he said. His advice: keep each application focused on one subject and one department. If the relevant records are difficult to identify, applicants can seek permission to inspect the files and select the documents they need.
He also cited Section 4, which requires authorities to proactively disclose specified information. Citizens should not have to repeatedly seek records that should be online. Galgali said follow-ups helped improve access to building-related records on the BMC’s website.
RTI, however, should not be the first response to every civic problem. When he recently found a parking plot in Dadar lying unused, he photographed it and posted the issue on X, tagging the relevant municipal ward. He also sent the post to senior civic officials.
When a problem is visible, he argued, citizens should seek action rather than another document. RTI records, however, can help pursue accountability.
Galgali cited a case involving an Air India computer procurement worth about Rs 250 crore. He said documents obtained through RTI helped him approach the Central Vigilance Commission, after which the complaint led to a CBI investigation.
“You need an authentic document,” he said.
Gokhale Bridge: Making officials keep their promises
For residents of Andheri, the closure of Gokhale Bridge disrupted traffic across a roughly six-kilometre stretch, affecting commuters, businesses and access to the airport.
Dhaval Shah recalled that officials initially indicated the bridge would reopen within six months. Residents recorded a public meeting with officials and elected representatives so they could refer to the assurances later.
“We wanted to hear every single thing and note it down for future reference,” he said.
The first phase opened after nearly two years and about seven missed deadlines, Shah said. A WhatsApp group grew to more than 1,000 members within a week. Residents submitted petitions, approached officials and kept the issue alive on social media. Shah credited sustained media coverage with helping the campaign.
Shah urged residents not to feel embarrassed about repeatedly seeking answers.
“Over the years we have become shameless. And I advise others to do so too. Only then can you demand and get response and action from the system,” he said.
LOCA records meetings and circulates minutes. Shah recalled an elected representative later trying to reinterpret an assurance that the bridge would reopen in May. Written commitments make it harder for officials to change their promises.
Shah cited a long-pending fire station reservation for Lokhandwala-Versova, saying the nearest station is about six kilometres away despite repeated fires. “Unless and until there is an episode, people don’t take interest in it,” he said.
For Shah, the lesson from Gokhale Bridge is that residents must organise before a crisis, stay involved after it and keep asking officials to honour their commitments.
From complaints to solutions: Three years to build a garden
In Matunga, residents spent three years trying to turn a neglected space beneath a flyover into a public garden and walkway.
Nikhil Desai said the campaign began after taxis started gathering beneath the flyover. Drivers wanted space to park and rest, while residents feared the area would become permanently occupied.
Desai persuaded the local ward office to temporarily block vehicle access. Residents then offered to beautify the space at their own cost and hand it over to the civic body for maintenance. But they discovered that the land belonged to the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), not the BMC.
MMRDA asked for a formal proposal. Residents from around 80 buildings suggested facilities including badminton and basketball courts. An architect prepared a plan estimated to cost more than Rs 4 crore. Desai recalled being asked to show that residents could raise around Rs 2 crore.
“We didn’t have even 40 rupees at the time,” he said.
The land was subsequently transferred to the BMC, forcing residents to start discussions again. Desai eventually approached the municipal commissioner with a different argument: why should citizens raise crores to develop a public space when the municipal garden department had funds for such work?
The administration agreed to examine the proposal. The space was eventually developed into a garden with a 700-metre walkway. Desai also recalled approaching then MP Rahul Shewale to secure a wider path for pedestrians.
Why do ward offices not respond?
“If you have a solution, in fact they do listen at higher levels. Ward level unfortunately has become non-answerable,” Desai said.
He cited a dispute over a proposed booth on the footpath outside Khalsa College in Matunga. Desai argued that the structure would obstruct students and pedestrians. After the ward office failed to resolve the issue, he repeatedly raised it at the municipal commissioner’s public grievance meetings, taking photographs, documents and a letter signed by around 200 people.
The commissioner eventually directed that the booth be removed and an alternative location considered, according to Desai.
He questioned why a citizen should have to approach the municipal commissioner to resolve a basic footpath complaint. The absence of an effective, time-bound citizens’ charter, he said, allows departments to delay responses without consequence.
“Any work is given, within how much time period you will give the answer and solve that thing,” he said.
Desai also criticised corruption, arguing that rules and penalties lose their value when officials find ways around them. Unless corruption is addressed, he said, lasting civic improvements will remain difficult.
Environmental battles: 15 years and counting
While Galgali uses information, Shah relies on resident mobilisation and Desai works through civic departments, environmentalist Stalin Dayanand has taken several disputes to court.
The Vanashakti director said environmental complaints can take years to resolve, even when violations are documented.
“For the state or the system to respond, you have to be very persistent. You can’t hide and just have a one-off message or a letter and expect things to move,” he said.
Stalin recalled confronting the dumping of nearly 500 truckloads of mud on a wetland in Wadala during the lockdown, after authorities allegedly failed to act. He pursued the matter for five years, including through the National Green Tribunal. However, the person responsible for the dumping was eventually fined just Rs 500, he said. Stalin argued that such nominal penalties do little to deter environmental violations.
He said some Wadala residents who complained about ready-mix concrete plants and air quality were intimidated at home after filing complaints and RTI applications.
“Intimidation, that happens. So, you have to be ready for that,” he warned. His advice was to build support rather than take on powerful interests alone. Even five or ten people standing together can make a difference, he said.
Stalin was also sceptical about involving politicians in environmental disputes, alleging that political interests can contribute to environmental damage. He recommended a sequence of filing a complaint, using RTI to seek records of action taken, following up and turning to legal remedies if the administration fails to respond. Vanashakti generally allows about six months of follow-up before considering litigation, he said.
The Ulhas river case
Stalin cited the Ulhas river pollution case as an example of what sustained legal action can achieve. He said proceedings in the Supreme Court resulted in the government paying Rs 100 crore over pollution in the river.
Municipal bodies discharging untreated sewage were subsequently required to establish treatment infrastructure, although he said Kalyan remained an exception at the time of the discussion.
“It took eight years for that,” he said. The wider effort to secure compliance from industries had continued for about 15 years.
He also cited the Sawantwadi-Dodamarg wildlife corridor, where 38 mining proposals threatened an ecologically sensitive area. He said the court cancelled a public hearing for one proposal despite restrictions on tree felling.
Stalin said the area received protection through a court decision in 2025, after a struggle lasting around 15 years. The case, he argued, showed that a legal order does not always end a dispute; authorities may still need to be pushed to comply.
Development versus conservation
Stalin questioned projects that, in his view, treat environmental damage as an unavoidable cost of development. He raised concerns about a proposed educational complex in the Film City area and questioned why alternative sites were not considered before forest land was affected.
“Is it a Tree Authority for preserving trees or for clearing trees?” he asked, arguing that saplings elsewhere cannot replace a mature forest.
“None of us say that India should not progress. You can save it and do it,” he said. The choice, he argued, should not be between development and the environment.
Kanjurmarg: The need for scrutiny
The Kanjurmarg dumping ground was another example of the gap between official assurances and public scrutiny. Stalin questioned the transparency of its operations and cited satellite-based reporting on methane emissions.
“If it is scientific, you will take students there. You will allow researchers to go and see how it is done. You will allow media to go in there,” he said, arguing that restricted access makes independent scrutiny difficult.
He also spoke about delays in litigation and the difficulty of enforcing favourable court orders. If authorities fail to comply, he said, citizens may have to file contempt proceedings.
“You have to hang in there and keep fighting. Persistence is the key,” he said.
Who gets a say in Mumbai’s development?
The discussion highlighted how little opportunity residents have to question major projects before decisions are made.
Shah said residents are often informed after key decisions have been made. He called for public meetings on infrastructure projects worth even Rs 200 crore.
Citing the Mrinaltai Gore flyover, he questioned differences between proposed and completed alignments, as well as defects in newly built roads and flyovers.
Stalin said Detailed Project Reports, environmental clearances and other project documents should be readily available. He recalled that obtaining Mumbai Metro 3’s Detailed Project Report had initially involved a demand for around Rs 80,000, before the documents were eventually made available online.
But residents also need to use the opportunities available to them. Shah recalled attending a public hearing on tree cutting at which only six people turned up, including him and a friend.
Residents complain that decisions are made without their consent, he said, but often skip hearings where they can object.
Redevelopment without infrastructure
Shah warned that redevelopment in Mumbai’s suburbs is outpacing improvements to basic infrastructure.
In Andheri, he said, buildings that once had four to seven floors are being replaced by towers of 30 to 35 floors. Roads, drainage, water supply and emergency services have not necessarily expanded at the same rate.
“You need an audit of the existing infrastructure and the carrying capacity of that locality,” he said.
He called for independent assessments before redevelopment permissions are granted, to establish how much additional population and traffic an area can support. LOCA has also pushed for road setbacks to make space for wider roads and utilities.
The question is whether Mumbai is planning for the people who will occupy these towers.
Can social media turn complaints into action?
Posting photographs, tagging the BMC and hoping a complaint goes viral has become a common response to civic problems.
Social media helps residents reach officials and mobilise support, but cannot replace follow-up.
Shah encouraged residents to join existing citizens’ associations or form neighbourhood groups. LOCA’s social media presence, which had about 32,000 followers at the time of the discussion, helps bring attention to issues that individual residents may struggle to raise.
Galgali recommended X for reporting visible civic problems, while Shah suggested tagging established residents’ groups to widen a complaint’s reach.
But the Gokhale Bridge campaign showed that online pressure must be backed by meetings, petitions, letters and direct engagement with officials. A viral post attracts attention; sustained follow-up is what keeps a department accountable.
The activists also cited public apathy and divisions within housing societies. Galgali criticised societies seeking favours such as benches and bins from politicians instead of demanding transparent use of public funds. Shah said party loyalties can weaken campaigns.
Stalin said collective action also protects activists from intimidation: “When you are alone, you are at great risk of being targeted.”
Is civic activism accessible to everyone?
RTI applications, repeated ward visits, public hearings and court cases require resources many Mumbaikars do not have. Residents’ groups can help, but the burden cannot rest on volunteers. Citizens should not need legal expertise, political connections or thousands of social media followers to secure a basic service.
Where should a Mumbaikar begin?
For potholes, blocked drains and encroached footpaths, the panelists offered practical starting points.
Galgali recommended the BMC’s 1916 helpline and X. Complaints directed to the relevant municipal ward can sometimes get a quicker response on social media, he said. For road-related problems, residents can approach the ward’s roads department or the BMC’s roads department. If the issue remains unresolved, RTI can be used to seek records of repairs, contractors, expenditure and action taken.
Shah suggested tagging established residents’ associations to bring wider attention to individual complaints.
For environmental violations, including mangrove destruction and dumping, Stalin advised documenting the incident and reporting it to the Forest Department or the relevant mangrove protection authorities. He also referred to the Mangrove Suraksha app and urged residents to keep written records of complaints. He cautioned that complainants’ personal details may be disclosed to those named in complaints, and suggested that people concerned about retaliation avoid publicly revealing their identity.
The activists also stressed the importance of protecting open spaces before they are occupied or their use is changed. Galgali cited campaigns to reopen Gandhi Maidan in Kurla and make a garden in Chandivali accessible. Shah recalled efforts to restore Lokhandwala Lake, including removing invasive vegetation and preventing idol immersion in the waterbody. A separate temporary immersion facility now accommodates around 3,000 idols each year, he said.
The fight for accountability
The four activists outlined different routes to civic action: official records, collective pressure, practical proposals and, when necessary, litigation.
Each approach has limits: RTI appeals are delayed, online campaigns lose momentum, departments pass responsibility and court orders can be difficult to enforce.
Citizens also have a role to play. Poor attendance at public hearings, indifference to redevelopment plans and the abandonment of complaints after an initial response weaken accountability. But that does not absolve the administration of its responsibility to provide basic services.
Why should residents spend three years securing a public garden, mobilise thousands to demand the reopening of a bridge or fight environmental cases for 15 years before institutions perform their duties?
Mumbai’s activists have shown that the system can be made to respond. What remains uncertain is whether it will do so without being forced.
The right to vote gives Mumbaikars a say in who governs them; the right to question and demand answers shapes the years between elections. Mumbai belongs to those who live in it as much as to those who govern it.
