The Hindu: Tiruppur: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Not satisfied by ‘evasive’ replies to their query on existence of Apex Committee under the RTI Act by the Water Resources Department, farmers in the tail-end of PAP Main Canal have gone for first appeal under Section 19(1) of the Act. In a representation to the Appellate Authority Officer and joint Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, P. Velusamy, on behalf of the farmers, had sought information on the constitution of the Apex Committee.
The stand taken by the Public Information Officer (PIO) that the information sought extensive/ voluminous and invoked Section 7(9) of the RTI Act, prompted the farmers to go on appeal. The PIO’s reply, Mr. Velusamy said, was ‘incomplete, evasive and legally unsustainable’, and questioned the rationale behind invocation of Section 7(9) of the RTI Act (to deny the details), which is applicable only in situations where the information would disproportionately divert the resources of public authority, or be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record.
The RTI application, Mr. Velusamy pointed out, had asked for identifiable documents, including GO/ notification on constitution of the Apex Committee; appointment/nomination order of the Chairman, present list of members; term/tenure of Chairman and members, official address and contact details; meeting details and minutes; and records establishing the constitution of the Committee after April 21, 2026. The WRD’s reply to an earlier RTI query on this date stated that the Apex Committee has not been constituted, and that its meetings had not taken place during the preceding three years.
The appeal also sought information on the documents/ instructions on the basis of which the learned Special Government Pleader represented before the High Court that the Apex Committee was already in existence and functioning; records relating to the receipt and implementation of the High Court order; action taken on the representation dated March 10, 2026; and relevant government orders, rules and proceedings governing the Apex Committee.
Transparency in these matters is directly connected with public accountability, lawful administration and the interests of thousands of registered ayacutdars dependent upon PAP system, Mr. Velusamy said, requesting the First Appellate Authority to furnish complete information.
Not satisfied by ‘evasive’ replies to their query on existence of Apex Committee under the RTI Act by the Water Resources Department, farmers in the tail-end of PAP Main Canal have gone for first appeal under Section 19(1) of the Act. In a representation to the Appellate Authority Officer and joint Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, P. Velusamy, on behalf of the farmers, had sought information on the constitution of the Apex Committee.
The stand taken by the Public Information Officer (PIO) that the information sought extensive/ voluminous and invoked Section 7(9) of the RTI Act, prompted the farmers to go on appeal. The PIO’s reply, Mr. Velusamy said, was ‘incomplete, evasive and legally unsustainable’, and questioned the rationale behind invocation of Section 7(9) of the RTI Act (to deny the details), which is applicable only in situations where the information would disproportionately divert the resources of public authority, or be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record.
The RTI application, Mr. Velusamy pointed out, had asked for identifiable documents, including GO/ notification on constitution of the Apex Committee; appointment/nomination order of the Chairman, present list of members; term/tenure of Chairman and members, official address and contact details; meeting details and minutes; and records establishing the constitution of the Committee after April 21, 2026. The WRD’s reply to an earlier RTI query on this date stated that the Apex Committee has not been constituted, and that its meetings had not taken place during the preceding three years.
The appeal also sought information on the documents/ instructions on the basis of which the learned Special Government Pleader represented before the High Court that the Apex Committee was already in existence and functioning; records relating to the receipt and implementation of the High Court order; action taken on the representation dated March 10, 2026; and relevant government orders, rules and proceedings governing the Apex Committee.
Transparency in these matters is directly connected with public accountability, lawful administration and the interests of thousands of registered ayacutdars dependent upon PAP system, Mr. Velusamy said, requesting the First Appellate Authority to furnish complete information.
