Indian
Express: New Delhi: Monday, 04 May 2015.
The Central
Information Commission has directed the Environment Ministry to place on its
web site the records related to Rs 16,000-crore Polavaram dam project after the
ministry told an RTI applicant that it was difficult to trace the documents as
they were over a decade old.
Suresh Kumar,
an environment scientist, has sought from the Ministry the details of Impact
Assessment of the controversial project in Andhra Pradesh but he was informed
that the records being a decade old are difficult to be located.
Kumar
complained that the official web site of the Ministry does not have information
as required by Section 4 (1)(b) of the RTI Act in the same manner as it was
provided for other projects, prompting him to file the RTI plea.
A Ministry
official, however, countered the allegations saying while most of the
information about the project has been provided on the web site, some documents
need to be digitised and posted on the portal.
He said delay
in furnishing information was because of exigencies related to various
projects, court cases before the Supreme Court, National Green Tribunal, and
High Court besides Parliament related works.
"The
Commission agreed with the contentions of the appellant that the 'failure to
trace records' would not exempt the public authority from their duty to provide
the information sought," Information Commissioner
Sridhar
Acharyulu said in the first ever order also issued in Telugu.The Information
Commissioner directed the Ministry to place all available information on
Polavaram project on their official web site.
"The
Commission also directs the PIO to furnish copies of environmental clearance
given at first instance, and also when the issue of environmental clearance was
revisited for Indira Sagar Polavaram project in West Godavari district in
Andhra Pradesh, file notings and correspondences along with minutes of
meetings...," he said.
The multi-purpose
dam and irrigation project has been accorded national project status by the
Centre. The project has attracted controversy after neighbouring states of
Odisha and Chhattisgarh raised the issue of submerged land in their states.