Monday, January 19, 2015

‘Negligence’ FIR against Gurgaon hospital for boy’s transplant death

Indian Express: Gurgaon: Monday, 19 January 2015.
The Gurgaon police filed an FIR against doctors and staff members of a private hospital here on Sunday for negligence that allegedly caused the death of a 10-year-old liver patient in 2011. The case was registered at Sadar police station after a court order.
Police said their teams are conducting an investigation and arrests may be made after taking reports from the civil surgeon.
Pankaj Arora, a resident of Rudrapur, Uttarakhand, complained to the police that his 10-year-old son died on July 30, 2011 in the hospital after he underwent two liver transplants, both unsuccessful. The FIR has been registered against five doctors Neelam Mohan, Parmanand Kulhari, Nischint Sharma, A S Soin and A K Dubey the hospital and the liver transplant team under sections pertaining to culpable homicide not amounting to murder, death due to negligence and forgery of documents.
The deceased was admitted to the hospital in October 2010, as he was suffering with autoimmune Hepatitis (Type 1) and was subsequently suggested liver transplant.
“We have not received any such information yet. We will be in a better position to answer once we receive such notice,” the official spokesperson of Medanta hospital said on Sunday.
According to Arora, Medanta doctors had suggested an immediate liver transplant, which was estimated to cost Rs 15 lakh. “As I could not afford the cost, I got a letter from the authorities so that free treatment could be provided to my son under EWS (economically weaker section) quota. The surgery was delayed by four months after the hospital came to know that the patient was from EWS quota,” Arora told Newsline.
He claimed the second surgery was conducted after the boy’s condition started deteriorating. He claimed there was a delay again as the “hospital refused to provide the second transplant free of cost”. The deceased had undergone treatment at the hospital for nine months and was admitted six times.
Explaining why it took three years to file a case, assistant commissioner of police, Rajesh Kumar, said, “According to CrPC, doctors cannot be interrogated directly and a certain process needs to be followed. One of our teams had been working on this and a parallel investigation was on as per the court’s directive, as the family moved the court after the incident.”
The father of the deceased had also sought information regarding doctors and the hospital through RTI, the police added. “The complainant took information through RTI till end of December 2014 and then complained to police. He found out through other doctors and RTI that the cause of death was negligence by the transplant team and by the doctors treating the child,” a senior police officer said.