Sunday, August 03, 2014

Padmashree: Shivraj's Padma proposals personal info, says MHA

Times of India: Bhopal: Sunday, 03 August 2014.
"Recommendations from Shivraj Chouhan for Padmashree awards this year is a personal information," is how home ministry said in its bizarre reply to a query under Right to Information Act.
In a query under right to information Act, Neemuch-based activist Jinendra Surana asked the office of prime minister about recommendations made by chief ministers of Madhya Pradesh between 2003 and 2014 (Uma Bharti, Babulal Gaur and Shivraj Singh Chouhan).
The letter was forwarded by the office of prime minister (PMO) to the home ministry. Home ministry in its reply dated July 4, said recommendations are only stored for one year hence the information related to years 2003 to 2013 is not available.
"In reference to 2014's recommendations, it is being informed that the above mentioned recommendation letters have personal information and hence could not be provided as per Section 8 (1) J of the RTI Act," home ministry said in the reply.
"From the reply of home ministry, it seems as if recommendations are for private awards and not Padmshree, which is one of most prestigious awards," Surana told TOI.
"I have also appealed against the decision of public information officer with appellate authority," Surana said.