Monday, August 18, 2014

No science to MTC’s route planning, shows RTI reply

Times of India: Chennai: Monday, August 18, 2014.
He sifts through letters and petitions to decide on whether an area needs more buses or in some cases, a new route. The Metropolitan Transport Corporation's deputy manager for planning sits in an office on Pallavan Salai that's out of touch with the changing city outside. Data is not collected scientifically to improve bus services for the ever-expanding city.
Operating 3,531 buses from 27 depots on more than 800 routes, MTC does not have transit experts or consultants on board, it said in an RTI reply to TOI. "For new routes, we usually look at representations from people and see if what they ask for is feasible," said an MTC official. "In the extended areas, if the Chennai Corporation has laid new roads, we might consider new routes on our own."
It does not increase frequency of services or modifications to routes based on scientifically collected data on commuter traffic.
The RTI reply also said that the corporation spent 1,096 per bus per month on maintenance of the GPS tracking and passenger information system. The systems were installed on 500 buses in 2008 and were removed in September 2013.
The systems were supposed to collect data on number of commuters to help MTC plan services but they were only on 500 buses, so the data could not be used to draw useful inferences. This data was also not available online and the private companies involved neither made the information public nor allowed third-party developers to build apps that could be used by commuters to find out the location of the buses.
In a report released last week, Comptroller and Auditor General of India also said that MTC made an investment in GPS/GPRS without proper financial arrangements. In 2008, MTC procured 495 onboard units at a cost of 83.6 lakh. It did not use any of them leading to a total loss of 2.87 crore between January 2008 and September 2012.
Though the MTC website gets close to 2,000 hits a day, it is updated only once a month. Information about changes to routes is not available. The only thing that gets updated on the site daily is the number of tickets sold. "The only information I can get from the website is the number of halts on a route. I can't get information if I'm taking more than one bus," said T Vinodh, a regular commuter.
According to the RTI reply, the website gets 1,905 hits a day, far lower than the number of tickets issued, which is an average of 32.3 lakh a day. "The website hits will be lower in reality as this number includes the number of page views, which is about three or four per person. In reality, the actual number is about 25% less than the quoted figure," said a source in the department.