Thursday, April 03, 2014

No RTI reply, BMC to pay Rs 50,000 to South Mumbai man

Times of India: Mumbai: Thursday, April 03, 2014.
The state chief information commissioner (CEC) has directed the BMC to pay Rs 50,000 compensation to south Mumbai resident Nandu P Kapadia who had sought information under an RTI application, but did not get it within the 30-day stipulated period resulting in his house on Princess Street being demolished.
This is the second such landmark ruling by the state CEC. In 2013, the Mumbai University was told to pay Rs 1 lakh compensation to an RTI applicant, who had sought records of the minutes of the management council meetings in the last 10 years.
After hearing Kapadia's complaint, state CEC Ratnakar Gaikwad directed the first appellate officer to ensure payment of the compensation before April 30, and issued a show-cause notice asking the officer to appear before him for clarifications. "If not, then a penalty will be imposed on the officer," the order said. The penalty can be up to Rs 25,000.
On October 11, 2013, Kapadia filed an RTI plea seeking information from the C ward office on certain documentary proof related to his property, which was under litigation, that had to be presented in court. When he did not get the information, he approached the first appellate officer on December 6, 2013. The officer ordered that Kapadia get the information within seven days, but he never got it.
Kapadia told Gaikwad that the official neither responded to his plea properly nor told him that he had to deposit an amount to get photocopies of the required documents. "He has suffered an irreparable loss following the inability of the officials in giving information within the stipulated timeframe," the order said.