Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Making building proposals public still a distant dream

DNA: Mumbai: Wednesday, March 19, 2014.
It seems the civic body's ambitious plan of ensuring transparency in compliance to building laws and other guidelines on building constructions in city by putting up details of approved building plans on the BMC website since 2001 lacks serious will. At least, according to BMC chief engineer Rajiv Kuknur, the civic body is not looking at any specific time frame for the completion of the task.
 "It is in process. There are some technical issues. We are not looking at any fixed time frame for this," Kuknur told dna.
Kuknur's reply, however, contradicts Shailesh Gandhi's words.
Gandhi, an RTI activist and the chairman of technical advisory committee for RTI at the civic body, said, "Details of some plans, have been uploaded on the BMC website. The rest should be uploaded in the next two months."
Asked about the compulsory display of boards at the construction sites, displaying name of the developer, Kuknur said, "They are taken away by beggars and other miscreants. There is nobody to monitor that. We can't do much about it," he said.
Several activists in the city, who have long been fighting for transparency in building proposals and their approvals, expressed shock at Kuknur's words. "How come other signages stay at place and only the ones at construction sites are stolen? Such instances bring to light the builder-politician nexus," said an activist, requesting anonymity. "They won't take risk before the elections as they won't like to disrupt the money flow that reaches them through builders. There is a kind of resistance from the civic officials too on this," said another activist.
Utsal Karani of Janhit Manch said not putting up such boards are a clear violation of the Development Control Regulations, which makes it mandatory for a builder to display the CTS and file numbers at the site. "Without CTS number, we cannot seek information under RTI," he said, adding, "I don't think uploading of the proposals will take place even after the elections. All the FSI frauds, illegalities and violations of building bye-laws, will be out in the open," he said.
The step, if implemented, would have ensured that property buyers make an informed choice, while buying a property. They, otherwise, have no means to know if the property, they are investing on, is legal. The system was first introduced in 2009 by the then municipal commissioner Jairaj Phatak.
As per the system, all building plans would be submitted on a disc and permissions and concessions will be granted online. The plans, which have been approved, then supposed to be displayed on the BMC's website.
Nitin Killawala, an architect, said the BMC authorities have started putting up concession reports online. "The sooner they do it, the better," he said. PK Das, another architect, said, "It is pointless to approach individual authorities for a CD, for information on a particular proposal. The public should have access to such information and it should be put up on the site," he said.