Times of India: Aurangabad: Saturday,
October 01, 2016.
A city-based
associate professor has sent a fresh complaint to the defence ministry alleging
discrimination during a recruitment process by Defence Institute of Advanced
Technology (DIAT) in Pune.
In support of
his claim, the associate professor has attached a bunch of
"self-contradictory" documents from the DIAT received under the RTI
Act. The DIAT - a deemed university funded by the defence ministry - had
published an advertisement on April 25, 2015, inviting applications for the
post of assistant professor in the technology management. It received as many
as 18 applications.
In an RTI
reply, the DIAT clearly stated that the scrutiny committee shortlisted nine
applicants - all holding a postgraduate degree in management. Subsequently, the
shortlisted candidates were called for an interview on September 12, 2015. The
interview was attended by all the shortlisted candidates, following which one
was provisionally selected and his name was published on DIAT's website on the
same night.
Unconvinced
with the selection, the Aurangabad-based associate professor, Dr Nitin Untwal,
challenged the decision of the selection committee and sent a letter to the
DIAT, claiming that the appointment was in violation of the University Grant
Commission norms. Untwal holds an MBA, MCom, PhD and has cleatred UGC SET.
Taking
cognisance of Untwal's letter, the National Commission for Scheduled Castes
(NCSC) has initiated a probe into the recruitment as the seat was reserved for
an OBC candidate. Untwal has also lodged a series of complaints with the Prime
Minister's Office (PMO). The PMO, in its reply, cited a Supreme Court judgment
in the case between one P Sushila and UGC for carrying out the recruitment
process.
According to
Untwal's complaint, out of the 18 applicants, nine were disqualified on the
grounds that they did not have a PG or a master's degree in management. He
added that eventually a candidate with an M-Tech degree was not only
shortlisted, but selected.
Moreover, an
RTI query with the National Institute of Technology in Calicut revealed that
M-Tech under mechanical engineering (industrial engineering and management) is
not equivalent to postgraduation in management.
In a fresh
complaint, Untwal cited that a letter sent by the DIAT to the UGC - a copy
which has been obtained under RTI on September 28, 2015 - the DIAT stated that
the essential qualification for the post were as per para 4.4.5 of the UGC
regulation 2010, which is a post graduate degree in management declared
equivalent by AICTE/AIU.
In its RTI
reply, the DIAT on May 23, 2016 stated that the essential qualification for the
position were as per para 4.4.6.1 of the UGC regulation 2010, which says that
"the essential qualification for the post is a postgraduate degree in
engineering and technology".
When
contacted, DIAT officials refused to comment. But in a reply to a query posed
via email, DIAT's joint registrar (administration) T V Ananthasubramanian said,
"I am directed to forward the following as our response: Dr Untwal was a
candidate for the position of assistant professor for technology management. He
was not found suitable by the duly constituted Selection committee and hence,
not selected. His various queries to DIAT and various other agencies and
authorities, including the Hon'ble Raksha Mantri/Chancellor, DIAT have been
replied. The DIAT has nothing more to add to the answers given earlier."
.JPG)
.JPG)
