Mumbai Mirror: Mumbai: Monday, 16 November 2026.
But directive from
appellate authority may still put dept’s books under the scanner
 |
RTI activist Yusuf Khan |
The state Public Works
Department (PWD) has stonewalled an Right to Information (RTI) activist’s
efforts to examine tendering process, payments and work allocation on a
technicality the department refused to divulge the details claiming that the
information was not available in the particular format sought, apart from
citing exemptions under the RTI Act.
However, PWD’s resistance
to an open, public examination of its records faced a setback when its first
appellate authority directed officials to allow inspection of competitive
tender rates and specified tender documents in separate RTI cases filed by the
same activist.
The RTI applications that
the PWD refused to answer were filed by Yusuf Khan with the PWD’s Integrated
Unit (Civil) Division in Mumbai. Khan sought payment vouchers, payment slips,
work orders, bills and tender-related information concerning works undertaken
under different government budget heads.
The 2 RTI queries PWD
rejected
In one application, he
sought payment vouchers and payment slips linked to individual contractors for
works under budget heads 2059 and 2216, the District Planning and Development
Committee (DPDC) budget and MOW-related works.
“When public funds are
spent on government works, there should be no ambiguity about who received the
money and against which work. Citizens have every right to seek accountability
for public expenditure. The department cannot cite the format of information
sought to deny access to records it holds,” Khan said.
The PWD rejected the
request, stating that payment details were not maintained in the format sought.
It referred to Sections 2(f) and 2(j) of the RTI Act, 2005, which define
information accessible under the law and the right to access records held by
public authorities.
However, the rejection did
not clarify whether Khan could inspect individual payment vouchers and slips
available with the department, even if a consolidated contractor-wise statement
was not maintained.
In another application,
Khan sought work orders and bills relating to three construction agencies — M/s
Nivrutti Anna Patole, M/s Meru Construction and M/s Dhanlakshmi Construction —
for the financial years 2022-23 to 2025-26.
The PWD denied the
information, invoking Sections 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, which
provide exemptions relating to commercial confidence and personal information.
The department cited the possibility of disclosure affecting the agencies’
commercial interests and maintained that Khan had not established a larger
public interest warranting disclosure.
“Government expenditure
cannot be placed beyond public scrutiny merely by invoking commercial
confidence or personal information. If the department believes that a
particular record attracts an exemption, it must justify withholding it under
the provisions of the RTI Act. Public money and the payments made against
public works require accountability,” Khan said.
Appellate authority steps
in
In contrast, the PWD’s
first appellate authority, in two separate proceedings, directed officials to
facilitate Yusuf Khan’s inspection of tender records.
In one case, the authority
directed the department to permit inspection of records containing
percentage-based competitive rates quoted in online open tenders. The
application covered tender notices issued over a three-year period. Officials
were also directed to provide the specified information within 30 days, without
charging a fee, subject to the conditions mentioned in the order.
A similar direction was
issued in a separate case concerning offline tender notices. Officials were
instructed to allow inspection of relevant records relating to a specified work
and provide the requested information within 30 days, without charging a fee.
“An appellate order has to
be complied with within the stipulated time. The department will have to
examine the records covered by the directions and facilitate inspection in
accordance with the order. However, disclosure of payment-related documents and
other records has to be considered separately, keeping in view the provisions
and exemptions under the RTI Act,” a PWD official said, requesting anonymity.
“The appellate orders are
significant because they recognise that existing government records must be
accessible to citizens. Tender rates and related documents are essential to
understanding how public contracts are awarded. Transparency must extend to scrutiny
of expenditure and payments made against the work,” Khan said.
The appellate orders,
however, apply to the specified tender-related records and do not constitute a
blanket direction to disclose all documents sought in the other RTI
applications.
Senior PWD officials did
not respond to Mirror’s request for comment till press time.