Saturday, November 21, 2026

Provide RTI documents free of cost if fee notice delayed, says Keralam Information Commissioner

Deccan Herald: Kozhikode: Saturday, 21 November 2026.
Ramakrishnan also clarified that applicants are required to pay a fee only while filing an RTI application and that no fee is needed for submitting appeals.
Keralam Information Commissioner T K Ramakrishnan has directed public authorities to provide documents sought under the Right to Information (RTI) Act free of cost if they fail to notify applicants about copying charges within the prescribed time.
Addressing reporters after a district-level hearing at the Kozhikode Collectorate on Friday, he said authorities were required to notify applicants within the stipulated period if any fee was payable for providing copies of requested records.
"If they failed to do so, the entire set of documents sought by the applicant should be supplied free of charge," he said.
The hearing saw the disposal of 20 appeal petitions, according to a statement issued by the Commission.
Ramakrishnan also clarified that applicants are required to pay a fee only while filing an RTI application and that no fee is needed for submitting appeals.
He stressed the need for public authorities to ensure that replies to RTI applications were complete and contained all mandatory particulars.
These include the dates of receipt of the application and issue of the reply, the name and designation of the Public Information Officer, the officer's signature, PAN, office seal, telephone number and email address.
In cases where copying charges were applicable, the reply should specify the cost per page, total number of pages, total amount payable and the relevant head of account for making the payment.
The address of the appellate authority and the time limit for filing an appeal should also be clearly mentioned, he said.
The Commissioner asked officials to comply with Section 4 of the RTI Act by proactively disclosing information and keeping departmental websites updated.
He also cautioned that misuse of the RTI Act would not be allowed.

Mumbaikars, make them listen : Dipti Singh

Mumbai Mirror: Mumbai: Saturday, 21 November 2026.
From RTI applications and social media campaigns to protests and court battles, three activists and an environmentalist show how citizens can turn complaints into accountability
Mumbai has more than 20 million people, but getting its administration to listen can feel like an endless struggle. A bridge closure paralyses traffic; a neglected space beneath a flyover takes three years of campaigning to become a garden; an environmental complaint leads to a 15-year court battle. Even obtaining information through an RTI application can become a prolonged exercise.
Broken roads, delayed projects, disappearing green spaces and illegal dumping leave residents asking: Who is responsible, where should they complain and what does it take to get action? Civic engagement often begins with reporting a pothole or writing to the municipal corporation. When nothing happens, most give up. A few persist.
That was the focus of an October 28 roundtable at Mumbai Mirror, titled ‘From Civic Complaints to Civic Action: Making the System Listen’. It brought together four activists who have spent years questioning authorities, mobilising residents and pursuing civic and environmental issues.
RTI activist Anil Galgali spoke about using public records to demand accountability. Dhaval Shah, co-founder of the Lokhandwala Oshiwara Citizens Association (LOCA), described how residents organised around infrastructure issues, including the Gokhale Bridge closure. Nikhil Desai, associated with Matunga’s Advanced Locality Management movement, shared how residents reclaimed neglected public spaces. Stalin Dayanand, director of environmental NGO Vanashakti, spoke about taking environmental disputes to court.
Their experiences showed how citizens are forced to monitor work government departments should do, but also offered practical lessons on how to press officials for action.
RTI: Can information force accountability?
For Anil Galgali, the Right to Information Act remains one of the most powerful tools available to ordinary citizens. Two decades after the law came into force, however, he believes delays have weakened its impact.
Galgali called RTI India’s “second freedom”, giving citizens the right to seek official records without explaining why. Authorities generally have 30 days to respond, but appeals can take years, he said.
“Every government wants that people don’t ask questions in RTI,” he said, criticising political parties for supporting transparency in opposition but becoming less enthusiastic about it when in power.
Galgali said applicants often weaken their requests by asking broad questions or seeking explanations instead of specific records.
“RTI is only a document,” he said. His advice: keep each application focused on one subject and one department. If the relevant records are difficult to identify, applicants can seek permission to inspect the files and select the documents they need.
He also cited Section 4, which requires authorities to proactively disclose specified information. Citizens should not have to repeatedly seek records that should be online. Galgali said follow-ups helped improve access to building-related records on the BMC’s website.
RTI, however, should not be the first response to every civic problem. When he recently found a parking plot in Dadar lying unused, he photographed it and posted the issue on X, tagging the relevant municipal ward. He also sent the post to senior civic officials.
When a problem is visible, he argued, citizens should seek action rather than another document. RTI records, however, can help pursue accountability.
Galgali cited a case involving an Air India computer procurement worth about Rs 250 crore. He said documents obtained through RTI helped him approach the Central Vigilance Commission, after which the complaint led to a CBI investigation.
“You need an authentic document,” he said.
Gokhale Bridge: Making officials keep their promises
For residents of Andheri, the closure of Gokhale Bridge disrupted traffic across a roughly six-kilometre stretch, affecting commuters, businesses and access to the airport.
Dhaval Shah recalled that officials initially indicated the bridge would reopen within six months. Residents recorded a public meeting with officials and elected representatives so they could refer to the assurances later.
“We wanted to hear every single thing and note it down for future reference,” he said.
The first phase opened after nearly two years and about seven missed deadlines, Shah said. A WhatsApp group grew to more than 1,000 members within a week. Residents submitted petitions, approached officials and kept the issue alive on social media. Shah credited sustained media coverage with helping the campaign.
Shah urged residents not to feel embarrassed about repeatedly seeking answers.
“Over the years we have become shameless. And I advise others to do so too. Only then can you demand and get response and action from the system,” he said.
LOCA records meetings and circulates minutes. Shah recalled an elected representative later trying to reinterpret an assurance that the bridge would reopen in May. Written commitments make it harder for officials to change their promises.
Shah cited a long-pending fire station reservation for Lokhandwala-Versova, saying the nearest station is about six kilometres away despite repeated fires. “Unless and until there is an episode, people don’t take interest in it,” he said.
For Shah, the lesson from Gokhale Bridge is that residents must organise before a crisis, stay involved after it and keep asking officials to honour their commitments.
From complaints to solutions: Three years to build a garden
In Matunga, residents spent three years trying to turn a neglected space beneath a flyover into a public garden and walkway.
Nikhil Desai said the campaign began after taxis started gathering beneath the flyover. Drivers wanted space to park and rest, while residents feared the area would become permanently occupied.
Desai persuaded the local ward office to temporarily block vehicle access. Residents then offered to beautify the space at their own cost and hand it over to the civic body for maintenance. But they discovered that the land belonged to the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), not the BMC.
MMRDA asked for a formal proposal. Residents from around 80 buildings suggested facilities including badminton and basketball courts. An architect prepared a plan estimated to cost more than Rs 4 crore. Desai recalled being asked to show that residents could raise around Rs 2 crore.
“We didn’t have even 40 rupees at the time,” he said.
The land was subsequently transferred to the BMC, forcing residents to start discussions again. Desai eventually approached the municipal commissioner with a different argument: why should citizens raise crores to develop a public space when the municipal garden department had funds for such work?
The administration agreed to examine the proposal. The space was eventually developed into a garden with a 700-metre walkway. Desai also recalled approaching then MP Rahul Shewale to secure a wider path for pedestrians.
Why do ward offices not respond?
“If you have a solution, in fact they do listen at higher levels. Ward level unfortunately has become non-answerable,” Desai said.
He cited a dispute over a proposed booth on the footpath outside Khalsa College in Matunga. Desai argued that the structure would obstruct students and pedestrians. After the ward office failed to resolve the issue, he repeatedly raised it at the municipal commissioner’s public grievance meetings, taking photographs, documents and a letter signed by around 200 people.
The commissioner eventually directed that the booth be removed and an alternative location considered, according to Desai.
He questioned why a citizen should have to approach the municipal commissioner to resolve a basic footpath complaint. The absence of an effective, time-bound citizens’ charter, he said, allows departments to delay responses without consequence.
“Any work is given, within how much time period you will give the answer and solve that thing,” he said.
Desai also criticised corruption, arguing that rules and penalties lose their value when officials find ways around them. Unless corruption is addressed, he said, lasting civic improvements will remain difficult.
Environmental battles: 15 years and counting
While Galgali uses information, Shah relies on resident mobilisation and Desai works through civic departments, environmentalist Stalin Dayanand has taken several disputes to court.
The Vanashakti director said environmental complaints can take years to resolve, even when violations are documented.
“For the state or the system to respond, you have to be very persistent. You can’t hide and just have a one-off message or a letter and expect things to move,” he said.
Stalin recalled confronting the dumping of nearly 500 truckloads of mud on a wetland in Wadala during the lockdown, after authorities allegedly failed to act. He pursued the matter for five years, including through the National Green Tribunal. However, the person responsible for the dumping was eventually fined just Rs 500, he said. Stalin argued that such nominal penalties do little to deter environmental violations.
He said some Wadala residents who complained about ready-mix concrete plants and air quality were intimidated at home after filing complaints and RTI applications.
“Intimidation, that happens. So, you have to be ready for that,” he warned. His advice was to build support rather than take on powerful interests alone. Even five or ten people standing together can make a difference, he said.
Stalin was also sceptical about involving politicians in environmental disputes, alleging that political interests can contribute to environmental damage. He recommended a sequence of filing a complaint, using RTI to seek records of action taken, following up and turning to legal remedies if the administration fails to respond. Vanashakti generally allows about six months of follow-up before considering litigation, he said.
The Ulhas river case
Stalin cited the Ulhas river pollution case as an example of what sustained legal action can achieve. He said proceedings in the Supreme Court resulted in the government paying Rs 100 crore over pollution in the river.
Municipal bodies discharging untreated sewage were subsequently required to establish treatment infrastructure, although he said Kalyan remained an exception at the time of the discussion.
“It took eight years for that,” he said. The wider effort to secure compliance from industries had continued for about 15 years.
He also cited the Sawantwadi-Dodamarg wildlife corridor, where 38 mining proposals threatened an ecologically sensitive area. He said the court cancelled a public hearing for one proposal despite restrictions on tree felling.
Stalin said the area received protection through a court decision in 2025, after a struggle lasting around 15 years. The case, he argued, showed that a legal order does not always end a dispute; authorities may still need to be pushed to comply.
Development versus conservation
Stalin questioned projects that, in his view, treat environmental damage as an unavoidable cost of development. He raised concerns about a proposed educational complex in the Film City area and questioned why alternative sites were not considered before forest land was affected.
“Is it a Tree Authority for preserving trees or for clearing trees?” he asked, arguing that saplings elsewhere cannot replace a mature forest.
“None of us say that India should not progress. You can save it and do it,” he said. The choice, he argued, should not be between development and the environment.
Kanjurmarg: The need for scrutiny
The Kanjurmarg dumping ground was another example of the gap between official assurances and public scrutiny. Stalin questioned the transparency of its operations and cited satellite-based reporting on methane emissions.
“If it is scientific, you will take students there. You will allow researchers to go and see how it is done. You will allow media to go in there,” he said, arguing that restricted access makes independent scrutiny difficult.
He also spoke about delays in litigation and the difficulty of enforcing favourable court orders. If authorities fail to comply, he said, citizens may have to file contempt proceedings.
“You have to hang in there and keep fighting. Persistence is the key,” he said.
Who gets a say in Mumbai’s development?
The discussion highlighted how little opportunity residents have to question major projects before decisions are made.
Shah said residents are often informed after key decisions have been made. He called for public meetings on infrastructure projects worth even Rs 200 crore.
Citing the Mrinaltai Gore flyover, he questioned differences between proposed and completed alignments, as well as defects in newly built roads and flyovers.
Stalin said Detailed Project Reports, environmental clearances and other project documents should be readily available. He recalled that obtaining Mumbai Metro 3’s Detailed Project Report had initially involved a demand for around Rs 80,000, before the documents were eventually made available online.
But residents also need to use the opportunities available to them. Shah recalled attending a public hearing on tree cutting at which only six people turned up, including him and a friend.
Residents complain that decisions are made without their consent, he said, but often skip hearings where they can object.
Redevelopment without infrastructure
Shah warned that redevelopment in Mumbai’s suburbs is outpacing improvements to basic infrastructure.
In Andheri, he said, buildings that once had four to seven floors are being replaced by towers of 30 to 35 floors. Roads, drainage, water supply and emergency services have not necessarily expanded at the same rate.
“You need an audit of the existing infrastructure and the carrying capacity of that locality,” he said.
He called for independent assessments before redevelopment permissions are granted, to establish how much additional population and traffic an area can support. LOCA has also pushed for road setbacks to make space for wider roads and utilities.
The question is whether Mumbai is planning for the people who will occupy these towers.
Can social media turn complaints into action?
Posting photographs, tagging the BMC and hoping a complaint goes viral has become a common response to civic problems.
Social media helps residents reach officials and mobilise support, but cannot replace follow-up.
Shah encouraged residents to join existing citizens’ associations or form neighbourhood groups. LOCA’s social media presence, which had about 32,000 followers at the time of the discussion, helps bring attention to issues that individual residents may struggle to raise.
Galgali recommended X for reporting visible civic problems, while Shah suggested tagging established residents’ groups to widen a complaint’s reach.
But the Gokhale Bridge campaign showed that online pressure must be backed by meetings, petitions, letters and direct engagement with officials. A viral post attracts attention; sustained follow-up is what keeps a department accountable.
The activists also cited public apathy and divisions within housing societies. Galgali criticised societies seeking favours such as benches and bins from politicians instead of demanding transparent use of public funds. Shah said party loyalties can weaken campaigns.
Stalin said collective action also protects activists from intimidation: “When you are alone, you are at great risk of being targeted.”
Is civic activism accessible to everyone?
RTI applications, repeated ward visits, public hearings and court cases require resources many Mumbaikars do not have. Residents’ groups can help, but the burden cannot rest on volunteers. Citizens should not need legal expertise, political connections or thousands of social media followers to secure a basic service.
Where should a Mumbaikar begin?
For potholes, blocked drains and encroached footpaths, the panelists offered practical starting points.
Galgali recommended the BMC’s 1916 helpline and X. Complaints directed to the relevant municipal ward can sometimes get a quicker response on social media, he said. For road-related problems, residents can approach the ward’s roads department or the BMC’s roads department. If the issue remains unresolved, RTI can be used to seek records of repairs, contractors, expenditure and action taken.
Shah suggested tagging established residents’ associations to bring wider attention to individual complaints.
For environmental violations, including mangrove destruction and dumping, Stalin advised documenting the incident and reporting it to the Forest Department or the relevant mangrove protection authorities. He also referred to the Mangrove Suraksha app and urged residents to keep written records of complaints. He cautioned that complainants’ personal details may be disclosed to those named in complaints, and suggested that people concerned about retaliation avoid publicly revealing their identity.
The activists also stressed the importance of protecting open spaces before they are occupied or their use is changed. Galgali cited campaigns to reopen Gandhi Maidan in Kurla and make a garden in Chandivali accessible. Shah recalled efforts to restore Lokhandwala Lake, including removing invasive vegetation and preventing idol immersion in the waterbody. A separate temporary immersion facility now accommodates around 3,000 idols each year, he said.
The fight for accountability
The four activists outlined different routes to civic action: official records, collective pressure, practical proposals and, when necessary, litigation.
Each approach has limits: RTI appeals are delayed, online campaigns lose momentum, departments pass responsibility and court orders can be difficult to enforce.
Citizens also have a role to play. Poor attendance at public hearings, indifference to redevelopment plans and the abandonment of complaints after an initial response weaken accountability. But that does not absolve the administration of its responsibility to provide basic services.
Why should residents spend three years securing a public garden, mobilise thousands to demand the reopening of a bridge or fight environmental cases for 15 years before institutions perform their duties?
Mumbai’s activists have shown that the system can be made to respond. What remains uncertain is whether it will do so without being forced.
The right to vote gives Mumbaikars a say in who governs them; the right to question and demand answers shapes the years between elections. Mumbai belongs to those who live in it as much as to those who govern it.

Friday, November 20, 2026

No Rs 10 IPO at 3 Shimla Post offices, RTI applicant returns empty-handed

Himachal Scape: Shimla: Friday, 20 November 2026.
A citizen seeking to file a Right to Information (RTI) application was unable to obtain a Rs 10 Indian Postal Order (IPO) after visiting three post offices in Shimla, highlighting a practical difficulty faced by applicants trying to exercise their statutory right to information.
The correspondent personally visited Shimla Panchayat Ghar Post Office, Combermere Post Office and the General Post Office, covering nearly three kilometres on foot in search of the Rs 10 denomination. However, the required postal order was not available at any of the three establishments visited.
The requirement was for a single Rs 10 IPO, the prescribed application fee under the Central Right to Information framework. Despite approaching three postal establishments in the state capital, the applicant returned without the required instrument.
The experience raises a question about the availability of low-denomination postal orders at individual post office counters, particularly for citizens who rely on them to submit RTI applications.
However, the non-availability of the Rs 10 IPO at these three locations does not, by itself, establish a general shortage across the postal network. Departmental sources indicate that the denomination has not been discontinued. The difficulty encountered appears to concern its availability at the counters visited.
The incident nevertheless highlights the inconvenience that even a seemingly minor supply issue can cause to citizens. For someone seeking information from a public authority, an inability to obtain the prescribed payment instrument can mean an additional trip, wasted time and a delay in filing an application.
The issue assumes significance in Himachal Pradesh, where access to transparency mechanisms has itself faced institutional challenges. The State Information Commission has witnessed prolonged vacancies, including that of the Chief Information Commissioner. A local resident, Capt Atul Sharma, had earlier approached the President of India seeking intervention over the vacancies.
While the two issues are different, both underline the importance of ensuring that the mechanisms intended to facilitate citizens’ access to information remain functional and accessible.
The availability of a Rs 10 postal order may appear to be a minor administrative matter, but for an ordinary citizen attempting to exercise a statutory right, it is an essential requirement.
Ensuring the availability of such basic instruments at post office counters would help prevent avoidable inconvenience and make the RTI process more accessible.

Public hearings and the 'sense of the people': A tool for democratic accountability : Cynthia Stephen

Deccan Herald: Opinion: Friday, 20 November 2026.
Critics disapproved the move, saying the process had no legal or constitutional sanction. Since the position was a constitutional one, the need was for the set procedure for the removal of the CEC.

INDIA bloc holds symbolic 'public impeachment' of CEC.Credit: X/@AICC

The attention of the entire country was on New Delhi when a public hearing was held on October 31 to symbolically ‘impeach’ Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar Gupta. Organised at the residence of the Congress president and the leader of opposition in the Rajya Sabha, Mallikarjun Kharge, by the combined Opposition parties and student groups who had been calling for the resignation of the CEC for several months, it was held to show public opinion against the CEC. Evidence had been piling up for months about the gaps in the SIR processes, the conduct of the elections of several state governments, and numerous issues with the electoral rolls in the states where Assembly elections had been conducted in preceding months. The public hearing was run like a mock parliamentary session, where several participants spoke and later passed the resolution to ‘impeach’ the CEC by a show of hands.
Critics disapproved the move, saying the process had no legal or constitutional sanction. Since the position was a constitutional one, the need was for the set procedure for the removal of the CEC.
Are public hearings a valid part of the political process? In fact, public hearings were an important innovation in the movement for Independence. They have been an important part of the civic response to governments even prior to Independence, to demand justice, gather evidence on government claims, and challenge the colonial authorities. In 1917, the Champaran Enquiry was held by Mahatma Gandhi, Rajendra Prasad, Brajkishore Prasad, and J B Kripalani, all lawyers, in Mothihari and Bettiah in Champaran, Bihar. Over 7,000 indigo farmers testified on their experience of forced indigo cultivation. This first-hand evidence of oppressive indigo farming practices by the colonials forced the end of the practice.
Another independent public inquiry was taken up by the Indian National Congress (INC) following the Jallianwala Bagh massacre. Led by Motilal Nehru, C R Das, and Gandhi, the inquiry collected hundreds of eyewitness accounts to compile a public record of atrocities, independent of the government official report on the incident. In the 1930s, Jawaharlal Nehru and associates founded the Indian Civil Liberties Union (ICLU), held open forums and published reports on instances of political repression, censorship, and police atrocities. In the 1970s, the People’s Union for Civil Liberties and the People’s Union for Democratic Rights were active in a number of people’s tribunals, which enquired into matters such as the effect of mega projects like dams and mines on affected populations, custodial violence, and communal riots.
In the 1980s, there were mass public hearings, called Jan Sunwais, to highlight the various widespread impacts on large and marginalised populations of mega dams, deforestation for mining, and so on. Such public hearings later officially entered the legal framework. The Jan Sunwais and the Right to Information Movement in Rajasthan from 1994 to 2005 became the precursor to the Right to Information law. It began with the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sanghatan (MKSS), which organised a public hearing on infrastructure works being undertaken in five Panchayats. Copies of official records such as muster rolls, bills, and vouchers were obtained by activists and read out in public. Villagers then responded with direct eyewitness accounts of fake muster rolls and non-existent roads and buildings for which fake bills had been raised and funds disbursed. This strategy proved to be a very powerful, evidence-based counter to entrenched corruption in public works. This strategy was later adopted in urban areas by slum organisations and gave impetus to the National Campaign for the People’s Right to Information, which successfully lobbied for the passing of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act).
The RTI Act’s provisions have now been formalised as social audits, keeping the local government bodies accountable by requiring them to present expenditure records to gram sabhas. Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) are also carried out using public hearings as mandated by law: a salutary instance of a government respecting the people’s demand for accountability and thus formalising the accountability.
There have been many public hearings in India. An influential one by the Indian People’s Human Rights Commission (IPHRC) enquired into the January 1993 Bombay riots, led by retired Bombay High Court Justices S M Daud and Hosbet Suresh. Their report, The People’s Verdict, was published in July 1993. The official Justice Srikrishna Commission also enquired into the riots. Human rights bodies such as PUCL and Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP) helped survivors file evidence before the Srikrishna Commission. Thus, even though the succeeding state government tried to disband the official commission, there was sufficient public pressure to ensure that the report was completed and presented in 1998, which largely corroborated the findings of The People’s Verdict.
It is clear that public hearings are in fact a part of the political arsenal of citizens in India to show the ‘sense of the people’ and their opposition to oppressive actions of government and other constitutionally appointed authorities.  This reading, applied to the People’s Parliament on October 31, which passed resolutions symbolically impeaching the CEC, is indeed a valid political way to convey the disapproval of the citizens of India, especially as their representatives were not allowed to speak on these and related issues in Parliament.
(The author is an independent writer and researcher)
Disclaimer: The views expressed above are the author's own. They do not necessarily reflect the views of DH.

Tripura Information Commission fines official Rs 25,000 for denying RTI info on Chakma law

Shillong Times: Agartala: Friday, 20 November 2026.
The Tripura Chief Information Commissioner Binoy Shankar Mishra has imposed the maximum penalty of Rs 25,000 on S. Prabhu, Additional Secretary of the Tribal Welfare Department, for unlawfully denying information sought under the Right to Information (RTI) Act regarding the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022.
The action came on an appeal filed by Jagdish Rawat, Office Secretary of the Chakma Development Foundation of India (CDFI), who had sought copies of communications, departmental opinions, representations from Chakma organisations, and certified copies related to the Chakma Customary Laws Act through an RTI application submitted in August 2023. According to officials, S. Prabhu, who was then serving as the Public Information Officer (PIO), rejected the request because the matter was pending before the State Legislature.
He also forwarded the application to a private organisation, the Chakma Miley Jodha (Chakma Women’s Association), seeking information from it. Hearing the appeal, the Information Commission ruled that the denial of information was legally unsustainable and that no legislative privilege had been established to justify withholding the documents.
The Commission also held that transferring the RTI application to a private organisation violated the statutory framework governing access to information. The Commission further observed that S. Prabhu acted both as the PIO and the First Appellate Authority, effectively reviewing his own decision, contrary to established legal principles.
It concluded that he had failed to provide any valid statutory basis for withholding the information and had not acted reasonably or diligently in discharging his responsibilities. The order noted a delay of 1,131 days in providing the information. While the penalty calculated at Rs 250 per day would have exceeded Rs 2.82 lakh, Section 20(1) of the RTI Act caps the penalty at Rs 25,000. The Commission therefore imposed the maximum permissible fine, stating that the officer had knowingly provided incorrect, incomplete and misleading information to the applicant.

Pvt varsities can’t claim blanket exemption under RTI, rules info commission

Times of India: Gurgaon: Friday, 20 November 2026.
A private university cannot automatically withhold information about its establishment, functioning and regulatory compliance by claiming it falls outside the Right to Information (RTI) Act, Haryana State Information Commission (SIC) has ruled.
The commission has directed Directorate General of Higher Education (DGHE), Panchkula, to examine its records on city-based Sushant University and obtain information from the university wherever the department has the legal authority to do so. The information must be given to the applicant free of cost within a month of receiving the order.
The order, passed by state information commissioner Dr Ajay Kumar Sura on Oct 22, came on an appeal by Yashwant Kumar. He had filed an RTI application on April 29, 2019, seeking details about the university, formerly known as Ansal University, but said the information was not furnished despite considerable time. He filed his first appeal on Jan 11, 2022, and a second appeal before the commission on April 11, 2022. The matter was heard in compliance with an earlier commission order dated Aug 20, 2025.
During the hearing, the university’s representative argued that Sushant University was a private, self-financed institution and not a public authority under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act, as it was neither owned, controlled nor substantially financed by the central or state govt. The representative also cited a June 12, 2023 communication from vice-chancellor Prof Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, which had told the applicant that the institution did not fall within the purview of the Act.
The commission held that private status alone was not sufficient ground to deny information. Even if a private institution is not directly covered by the Act, it said, information relating to it can be accessed through a govt authority that has the legal power to obtain such records under another law. Citing Sections 2(f) and 2(j), the commission noted that the Act’s definition of information also covers records of private bodies that public authorities can legally access.
The applicant’s questions covered when and under which legislation the university was established, the orders under which it came into existence, and who its chancellor is and which authority appoints the incumbent. He also sought details of students admitted under Haryana domicile categories since the university’s establishment, and the number who received fee concessions, with corresponding figures; the total number of physically and mentally disabled students admitted since then, and the facilities and provisions available to them under govt rules; copies of orders and guidelines issued to the university by University Grants Commission, govt and other regulators, and whether the university complied with them, along with certified copies of compliance reports submitted to regulatory authorities.
Identifying DGHE Haryana as the state’s regulatory authority for higher education, the commission observed that the department may have access to records on the university’s establishment, recognition, functioning and compliance, subject to powers under applicable laws and regulations.
It directed the SPIO-cum-assistant director in the DGHE office to examine each question individually, verify records available with or under the control of the department, and determine what additional information can legally be obtained from the university. The officer must also check information already supplied and correct deficiencies, replacing incomplete, blank or illegible pages with complete, readable copies and providing certified copies of official records wherever sought.
If particular information is neither available with the department nor legally obtainable from the university, the applicant must be informed specifically, with reasons. The department will not have to generate fresh information or provide explanations that are not part of existing records.
The commission has fixed the next hearing for Dec 7, 2026, at 11 am, and directed both parties to appear in person to report compliance. A copy of the order has been sent to DGHE Haryana for necessary action.
It referred to Delhi High Court’s judgment in Telecom Regulatory Authority of India v Kabir Shankar Bose (2018), which recognised that a public authority must obtain information from a private body and provide it under the RTI Act where it has the requisite legal entitlement. It also cited Supreme Court’s observations in CPIO, Supreme Court of India v Subhash Chandra Agarwal (2020) and CBSE v Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011), which stress transparency but clarify that authorities need not create fresh information, opinions or explanations that do not exist in official records.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Manipur’s displaced families deserve to know where relief funds go : Naorem Mohen

India Today NE: Opinion: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
At Manipur University, Prof. Khelena Gurumayum asked whether citizens can find out how rehabilitation money is spent and who receives assistance. The answers matter in a state where years of violence and displacement have eroded public trust.
When a rehabilitation package is announced, a displaced family in Manipur has immediate questions. Do we qualify for help to rebuild our home? Has our application been processed? If it is still pending, who can tell us why? The answers may determine where the family will live and whether its children will have to change schools again. It should be able to get those answers without making repeated trips to a district office.
At Manipur University’s November 18 awareness programme on the Right to Information Act, political scientist Prof. Khelena Gurumayum connected those questions to a basic principle of democracy. Elections give citizens a say in who exercises public power. Between elections, citizens must be able to ask those in authority to account for their decisions. Information held by public institutions, she argued, is a public resource. In Manipur, where violence since May 2023 has uprooted families, disrupted livelihoods and strained relations between citizens and the state, access to that information has particular weight.
The programme also marked the release of an RTI handbook for Central Public Information Officers (CPIOs) and First Appellate Authorities (FAAs). The release gave practical expression to the programme’s theme of strengthening transparency and accountability in public institutions. Information officers must help applicants, locate records and respond clearly.
Appellate authorities must examine whether a refusal or an inadequate reply can be justified. The handbook’s value will be measured in how those duties are carried out, whether the person seeking an answer is a student asking about examination rules or a displaced parent trying to find out where a housing claim stands.
Follow the money to the household
Gurumayum Khelena asked how much had been sanctioned for relief and rehabilitation, how much had been released and how the government was assessing whether its programmes were working. These are questions for taxpayers as well as displaced families. The answers would help the public judge whether assistance is reaching eligible households fairly across districts and communities.
The Union Ministry of Home Affairs records that it released ₹229.25 crore to Manipur in 2024–25 to operate relief camps. Its 2025–26 special package lists ₹119 crore in additional housing support for 7,000 households, at ₹1.70 lakh per household over and above the Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana–Gramin grant. Manipur’s government should make the next part of the record easy to follow. How much did each district receive and spend? How many households received payments? How many claims are pending, and for how long? Where housing payments have been made, how many homes have been completed?
Gurumayum Khelena also stressed the dignity and privacy of displaced people. The state can publish district-wise expenditure, eligibility rules and the number of households assisted while giving families a private way to check their own claims. If an application is held up, the family should be told the reason and whom to contact. In a state where rumours about who received help can deepen mistrust between communities, verifiable public records give people a common basis for questioning how relief is distributed.
A portal is only the beginning
Poor record-keeping, delayed replies, backlogs at information commissions and refusals with inadequate explanations were among the problems Prof Khelena identified. An online portal can make an RTI request easier to file and track. A timely, useful reply depends on whether the responsible office can locate the record and provide it in a form the applicant can use. Section 4 of the RTI Act requires public authorities to maintain records and proactively disclose specified information. For relief schemes, the state should explain eligibility, application procedures and where to seek help at camps and district offices as well as online.
Gurumayum Khelena drew attention to women who have organised relief, cared for displaced people and worked for peace since the conflict began. She asked what empowerment means in practice for a woman who is herself displaced or facing financial hardship. Can she find out what assistance she qualifies for? Can she question a delay and receive an answer? Access to that information gives her a way to claim her entitlements and hold the responsible office to account.
Manipur University can start with its own records
A publicly funded university that encourages students to think critically, Khelena said, should be prepared to answer legitimate questions about its own decisions. At the programme, Dr Sakila Nongmeikapam, the university’s Public Relations Officer and Central Public Information Officer, reported that Manipur University scored 67.5 per cent in its first third-party RTI transparency audit for 2025–26. She called for better record-keeping, closer coordination between departments and more regular updates to the university website. Publishing the steps taken after the audit would allow students, staff and applicants to see what has improved.
Controller of Examinations T. Shantikumar Singh gave a practical example. Students sometimes seek re-evaluation when the university’s rules provide for re-scrutiny, which checks for unmarked answers and errors in totalling or carrying forward marks. A clear notice on the examination portal could explain what students can apply for and how.
Prof. Yumnam Premananda Singh, Head of Manipur University’s Department of Law, urged information officers to help applicants who cannot put an RTI request in writing. That assistance is a legal duty. Under Section 6(1) of the Right to Information Act, the Central or State Public Information Officer must provide reasonable assistance to put an oral request in writing when the applicant cannot do so.
The Act also sets out what an officer must tell an applicant when a request is rejected. Under Section 7(8), the officer must give the reasons for the rejection, the deadline for filing an appeal and the details of the appellate authority. For a displaced person seeking records on rehabilitation spending or the status of a housing claim, these safeguards matter at both ends of the process. They help the person get the request on record and know where to turn if access is refused.
Registrar and First Appellate Authority Prof. M. Premjit Singh stressed the importance of recording the reasons for decisions when they are made. In an RTI appeal, a clear record helps the appellate authority examine how the original decision was reached and whether the applicable rules were followed. It also gives the university a basis for explaining its decision to the person affected.
Vice-Chancellor Prof. R.K. Hemakumar Singh called on departments to share responsibility for maintaining the records needed to answer RTI requests. An information officer can coordinate a reply, but the department that made the decision often holds the relevant files. Whether the university can give a student or staff member a complete answer depends on how well each department keeps its records.
How transparency can earn trust
Finance Officer Prof. L. Rajendrakumar Singh recalled an administrative culture in which decisions were made behind closed doors and files moved from table to table while citizens waited. Without access to the records behind a decision, people struggled to challenge delays, favouritism or misuse of public funds. He described the way forward in three words, “transparency, trust, and transformation.” When officials know that decisions about purchases, expenditure or examinations can be scrutinised, he argued, they have a reason to keep accurate records and explain how they applied the rules. Citizens can then judge for themselves whether an institution acted fairly.
Rajendrakumar linked stronger implementation of RTI to the need to restore people’s faith in Manipur’s public institutions. Rehabilitation offers a practical test. If the same problem is holding up dozens of housing claims, the administration can use its records to identify where the process breaks down and fix it.
For a displaced family, the change will be felt in an ordinary exchange at a district office. The family asks what happened to its application. An officer opens the record, explains where the claim stands and says who is responsible for the next step. After years of uncertainty, a family should be able to count on that answer.
Manipur University’s November 18 programme brought the Right to Information Act into the everyday work of public institutions. A student asking how examination marks were checked and a displaced family trying to find out where its housing application stands are both entitled to a clear answer.
Giving that answer begins long before anyone files an RTI request. It begins when an office records why it made a decision, keeps that record accessible and takes responsibility for explaining it. That was the practical lesson of the Manipur University programme, and it is one that every public institution in Manipur can act on.
Edited By: Aparmita

CIC Directs GeM to Disclose Cartelisation Findings

Rediff Money: New Delhi: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
CIC orders GeM to reveal internal findings on cartelisation, market concentration, and repeat seller orders after GeM cited commercial confidentiality under RTI.
The Central Information Commission (CIC) has directed the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) to provide an RTI applicant general findings of its internal assessments on cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, after the platform acknowledged analysing repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers but refused to disclose related reports.
GeM, launched by the Centre on August 9, 2016, is an online platform for the procurement of goods and services by government ministries, departments, public sector undertakings and other government organisations.
The RTI applicant had also asked about a purported "link facility" through which procurement or bid links were allegedly sent to selected sellers. GeM, however, denied the existence of any such facility on its portal.
In an order, Information Commissioner Khushwant Singh Sethi directed GeM to provide the general findings emerging from its reports, reviews or risk assessments concerning cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, if any, maintained by it.
The applicant, Goutam Mohanta, had specifically sought copies of reports, reviews or risk assessments maintained by GeM concerning cartelisation, concentration of procurement orders among sellers and creation of entry barriers.
The CIC directed the platform to "provide a specific and point-wise reply" indicating the findings emerging from these reports, reviews or risk assessments, if any.
The direction came after GeM, in response to another part of the RTI application, acknowledged that it conducts internal analysis regarding repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers or groups of sellers.
However, it refused to disclose the related reports, claiming that the information was commercially confidential and market-sensitive.
GeM invoked Section 8(1)(d) of the RTI Act, 2005, to deny the information, stating that its disclosure was likely to adversely affect the competitive position of sellers.
The commission observed that the exemption had been claimed in a general and mechanical manner without demonstrating how disclosure of the specific information would adversely affect the competitive position of any third party.
"The mere description of information as commercially confidential or market-sensitive, without establishing the applicability of the statutory exemption, is not sufficient to deny access under the RTI Act," the commission said.
The applicant had also sought details about the introduction of a purported "link facility", including its policy objectives, beneficiaries, monitoring mechanism and audit trail, alleging that procurement links were being sent to selected sellers.
GeM said the query was not clear and informed the applicant that "there is no such link facility on the GeM portal".
It consequently did not provide responses to subsequent questions on whether such a facility could result in certain sellers repeatedly receiving opportunities to participate in similar bids.
In response to another query, GeM informed the applicant that 3,36,904 unique sellers had received orders on the platform till date. However, it said it did not maintain data on the number of unique sellers participating or the percentage of transactions concentrated among a limited number of repeated sellers, as the data was dynamic in nature.
On measures to prevent cartelisation, GeM said it examines complaints received through official channels and acts against firms involved in cartelisation in accordance with its General Terms and Conditions and Incident Management Policy.
"Buyers are also enabled to view network-related details of participating bidders to identify cartelisation and take appropriate action," GeM said.
The platform also said it provides system-enabled filters for MSME, women entrepreneurs and SC/ST seller categories to promote inclusive participation.
The commission also examined the applicant's request for year-wise procurement figures through GeM by the Indian Army, BSF, SSB, CRPF and other paramilitary forces.
GeM had initially invoked Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act, relating to information held in a fiduciary capacity, to deny the figures. During the hearing, its representatives claimed exemption under Section 8(1)(a).
The commission observed that GeM had not adequately explained the justification for the exemption and directed it to furnish a revised and categorical reply, identifying the relevant exemption clause and providing cogent reasons if any information was withheld.
According to figures furnished in the RTI reply, GeM recorded government procurement orders worth Rs 5.42 lakh crore in 2024-25. The second appeal was disposed of with these directions.
Source: PTI   By Rediff Money Desk, New Delhi
DISCLAIMER - This article is from a syndicated feed. The original source is responsible for accuracy, views & content ownership. Views expressed may not reflect those of rediff.com India Limited.

SC seeks Centre's response on plea to bring Collegium decisions under RTI : Bhavini Mishra

Business Standard: New Delhi: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
The petition seeks greater transparency in judicial appointments, including bringing Collegium decisions under the RTI Act and finalising the Memorandum of Procedure
The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Centre and its secretary general on a petition seeking greater transparency in judicial appointments, including bringing Collegium decisions within the ambit of the Right to Information (RTI) Act and finalising the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) governing the appointment of judges to constitutional courts.
A Bench of Justices M M Sundresh and P B Varale issued notice on a plea filed by NGO Lok Prahari.
The petition also sought directions to the Chief Justice of India (CJI), in his administrative capacity, to initiate the process of revising the MoP in accordance with the Supreme Court's 2015 judgment striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC).
During the hearing, Justice Sundresh initially questioned whether he should hear the matter, given his position as a member of the Supreme Court Collegium.
"Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of collegium," he observed.
Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for the petitioner, said he had no objection to the judge hearing the case, pointing out that several judges who might hear the petition would also be members of the Collegium.
"Many of your lordships will be members of collegium. That objection will never go away," Hegde submitted.
The judge subsequently agreed to issue notice, while observing that the petition could have been drafted better. The court permitted the petitioner to file an amended plea.
The petition contends that the existing MoP lacks adequate transparency and objective criteria for selecting judges, affecting the quality of appointments and the performance of constitutional courts.
It argues that a clearly defined selection framework is necessary to safeguard litigants' access to justice.
Lok Prahari has sought directions for the Centre's Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the MoP within a month of consulting the CJI. It has also urged that appointments be guided by the unanimous view of the Collegium, taking into account the principles laid down in the 2015 NJAC judgment.
The MoP was first framed in June 1999 following the Supreme Court's directions in the Second Judges case. It prescribes the process for appointments to the higher judiciary under the Collegium system.
The framework came under scrutiny after Parliament enacted the NJAC Act in 2015, seeking to replace the Collegium with a commission comprising members of the judiciary and the executive.
However, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court struck down the law on October 16, 2015, holding that it violated the independence of the judiciary.
Following the verdict, the court invited suggestions to improve the Collegium system and, in December 2015, entrusted the Centre with revising the MoP. Differences between the government and the judiciary, however, delayed its finalisation.
In March 2017, the Supreme Court rejected the Centre's proposal to give the government the power to reject candidates recommended for judicial appointments on grounds of national security. The court also did not accept the proposal for a permanent secretariat for the Collegium.
The delay prompted another round of judicial intervention in October 2017, when a Bench of Justices A K Goel and U U Lalit sought the Centre's response on the prolonged delay in finalising the MoP.
The order, however, was subsequently recalled by a Bench headed by then CJI Dipak Misra.
Justice P S Narasimha had recused himself from the present matter when it was first taken up on November 2, citing his earlier appearance as an additional solicitor general in a similar dispute concerning the MoP.

Two VACB wings exempted from RTI Act only to protect confidential information, Kerala HC told

Times of India: Kerala: Thursday, 19 November 2026.
The vigilance director has informed the high court that the recent govt notification exempting the T1 and T2 sections of the directorate of vigilance and anti-corruption bureau (VACB) from the purview of Right to Information Act aims only to protect confidential information, including source reports, surprise checks and personal files, and prevent premature disclosure that could derail investigations.
In an affidavit filed in response to PILs challenging the notification dated Oct 22, vigilance director Manoj Abraham stated that the exemption was strictly confined to sensitive intelligence and did not grant a blanket exemption to the agency. The petitioners alleged that the impugned notification effectively excludes information relating to vigilance inquiries, intelligence inputs and records concerning suspected corruption and misconduct in public administration from the statutory framework governing access to information.
Abraham stated that the VACB has 52 sections dealing with vigilance inquiries, criminal investigations and related administrative matters, of which T1 and T2 are two. The T2 section deals exclusively with sensitive information, including files relating to source reports and intelligence inputs, orders for surprise checks, confidential verifications and petitions. The T1 section also deals with sensitive information of the same nature, besides the annual confidential reports of the bureau’s ministerial and executive staff and the personal files of executive staff of the rank of inspector of police. Since information relating to the service matters of vigilance personnel is not sensitive, such records have been reassigned to the Establishment section, the affidavit stated.
The affidavit further contended that disclosing the existence of confidential verifications, particularly in disproportionate assets cases, would enable corrupt officials to destroy evidence and intimidate informants. It noted that Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act offers inadequate protection before a formal case is registered. Premature disclosure of the existence or contents of a source report, intelligence input, confidential verification or surprise check would alert the public servant concerned, enabling him to conceal or transfer assets, destroy or fabricate documents, and influence witnesses, particularly in disproportionate assets cases.
The VACB has urged the court not to interfere with the notification, asserting that the exemption is essential for effective anti-corruption administration.