Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Punjab RTI Order Exposes the Limits of Secrecy in Public Hospitals : By Ananya Sharma

Urban Acres: Chandigarh: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
A Punjab RTI order directing Civil Hospital Kharar to disclose a Medical Board opinion has brought a recurring governance problem into focus: how public institutions should protect third-party information without blocking access to official records needed to defend oneself in court. The State Information Commission’s decision does not determine the merits of the criminal case linked to the records. It instead establishes that the nature of a document, the institution that created it and the purpose for which it is sought can matter when authorities consider an exemption under the Right to Information Act.
The case arose from a dispute connected to an FIR and a cross daily diary report registered at Nayagaon police station in Mohali on August 30, 2025. A Mohali resident approached the senior medical officer of Civil Hospital, Kharar, seeking certified copies of the final opinion prepared by a Medical Board, the police letter that led to the Board’s constitution and communications issued by the hospital or the Board requiring his appearance.
The Medical Board comprised three senior medical officers and was constituted at the government hospital on a request from the police. According to the account before the Commission, the Board submitted its opinion to the investigating officer on January 29, 2026. The appellant argued that the records were directly connected with criminal proceedings pending before a competent court and were essential to his defence.
The hospital authorities had earlier resisted disclosure on the ground that the information concerned a third party. That objection reflected a legitimate tension within the RTI framework. Public records can contain personal, medical or otherwise sensitive information relating to people who are not applicants. At the same time, a blanket refusal can prevent a person from obtaining documents that may be relevant to legal proceedings, particularly when those documents were generated by public officials in the course of their duties.
The Commission’s order turned on this distinction. It noted that the Medical Board had been constituted by a government hospital after receiving a police communication and that its opinion had been prepared by government medical officers as part of their official work. The Commission also considered the appellant’s stated requirement for the documents in order to defend himself in the pending criminal proceedings.
During the hearing, a medical officer appeared on behalf of the respondents and produced the complete official record in a sealed envelope, complying with the Commission’s earlier directions. After hearing the parties and examining the records, the Commission directed that the information sought in the RTI application be supplied. The sealed envelope was subsequently opened and the documents were provided to the appellant during the hearing.
This sequence is important because it shows that the dispute was not resolved simply by treating the information as either wholly private or wholly public. The records were examined in the context of the request, the institution that generated them and the stated legal purpose for which they were required. The Commission’s reasoning, as reported, places emphasis on the records’ official character and their connection with an ongoing criminal proceeding.
The order also draws attention to the role of government hospitals beyond routine treatment. Civil Hospital Kharar became part of a chain involving the police, medical officers, the RTI mechanism and the court process. Its doctors were not acting only as healthcare providers in the ordinary sense. They were also performing an institutional function through a Medical Board constituted after a police request.
That institutional position creates accountability obligations. When a document is prepared by public employees in a public facility and transmitted to an investigating officer, questions about its creation, contents and handling can affect the rights of people involved in a case. The Commission did not state that every medical record must be disclosed to every applicant. Its decision was tied to the circumstances presented before it, including the appellant’s demonstrated requirement for the documents in his defence.
The Commission relied on the Supreme Court’s 2011 judgment in The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India versus Shaunak H Satya. As described in the report, that judgment explained that the RTI Act seeks to harmonise transparency and accountability with the protection of other legitimate interests. That principle is central to the Kharar dispute. RTI administration is not only about expanding disclosure; it is also about applying exemptions in a manner that recognises competing rights and interests.
The order therefore has a significance beyond the individual records. It illustrates how public authorities can face difficulty when an RTI request involves information about another person but is also connected with the applicant’s legal rights. The initial response from the hospital treated the third-party aspect as a reason for withholding the material. The Commission’s eventual decision required a closer examination of the document’s official source and the purpose for which it was sought.
The case also demonstrates the importance of documentary custody. The respondents produced the complete record in a sealed envelope before the Commission. This allowed the Bench to examine the documents rather than decide the dispute only on a general description of their contents. The record included the final Medical Board opinion, the police communication that initiated the process and hospital or Board communications concerning the appellant’s appearance.
For public institutions, the practical issue is not merely whether a file exists. It is how the file is classified, who holds it, whether it contains information relating to more than one person and whether the requested material has a direct bearing on another legal process. The Kharar order indicates that these questions may have to be assessed together rather than through a single broad objection.
The decision also preserves the separation between information disclosure and adjudication of the underlying dispute. The Commission expressly clarified that it was not commenting on the merits of the criminal proceedings, the correctness of the Medical Board’s opinion or the innocence or guilt of any person. Those matters remained within the jurisdiction of the competent court.
This limitation is significant. Access to a document does not amount to a finding that the document is accurate, conclusive or favourable to the person who obtains it. Nor does an RTI order replace the evidentiary process before a court. The Commission’s role in this case was to decide whether the requested information should be disclosed under the circumstances placed before it.
That separation can help prevent two common misunderstandings about RTI disputes. First, disclosure is not the same as endorsement of the contents of a record. Second, an exemption dispute does not itself decide the underlying criminal allegation. The Commission’s order dealt with access to information, while the court proceedings will determine the legal issues arising from the FIR and cross daily diary report.
The case also underlines the importance of the second-appeal mechanism in the RTI system. The applicant had first sought information from the Civil Hospital, Kharar, and later pursued a second appeal before the State Information Commission after the information was not supplied. The Commission’s intervention created a forum where the competing claims could be examined and where the original records could be produced for scrutiny.
At the same time, the reported order does not establish how frequently similar requests are made to government hospitals, how long the earlier refusal lasted or whether the Commission has issued broader procedural directions to hospitals across Punjab. Those questions are not answered in the supplied material. The decision should therefore be read as an order based on the particular facts before the Commission, not as a universal ruling that all medical information connected to criminal cases must be released.
The larger urban governance question is how public institutions manage records that sit at the intersection of service delivery, policing, medical assessment and legal process. Government hospitals are often among the most visible points of contact between residents and the state. Their administrative records can influence investigations and court proceedings, while their handling of information affects public confidence in institutional accountability.
The Punjab case confirms that the existence of third-party information cannot, in every circumstance, end the inquiry. Authorities must also consider whether the material was created through an official process and whether the applicant has shown a specific and legally relevant need for access. It leaves intact the protection of legitimate privacy and the jurisdiction of the courts over the criminal case.
The next stage is not a further finding by the Information Commission on guilt or responsibility. It is the use of the disclosed documents, if relevant, within the pending proceedings before the competent court. The order’s immediate outcome is narrower but important: records created by a government hospital for a police-linked Medical Board process were supplied after the Commission found that withholding them could adversely affect the appellant’s ability to present material in his defence.

Lokpal withdrew jt secretary recruitment ad after whistleblower Sanjiv Chaturvedi application: RTI

Times of India: Dehradun: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Lokpal of India withdrew its recruitment process for the post of joint secretary on Aug 17, citing “administrative reasons”, nearly four months after advertising the vacancy and receiving an application from Uttarakhand cadre Indian Forest Service officer and whistleblower Sanjiv Chaturvedi, an RTI response filed by Dehradun-based activist Bhupendra Chanda has revealed. The RTI reply said that the anti-corruption ombudsman had cancelled the exercise without explaining the decision.
Lokpal issued the vacancy circular on April 27, inviting applications for the post. Chaturvedi applied, and Uttarakhand govt forwarded his application on June 13, conveying its no-objection and consent for his deputation. However, Lokpal withdrew the circular on Aug 17, stating that no further action would be taken on applications received under it.
The cancellation marked another setback in Chaturvedi’s efforts to secure a deputation to Lokpal, which began in Dec 2019. On Dec 23 that year, Uttarakhand govt forwarded his request to the Union ministry of environment, forest and climate change (MoEF&CC) with its consent. The ministry sought a copy of the vacancy advertisement on Feb 5, 2020, but took no substantive action for nearly two and a half years, prompting Chaturvedi to approach Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT).
During the proceedings, CAT asked Centre to show “magnanimity and openness” while considering his request. On Sept 1, 2022, it directed the secretary of MoEF&CC to decide the matter within eight weeks in consultation with the department of personnel and training (DoPT).
However, the ministry returned his application through an order dated Oct 3, 2022, signed by a director-rank officer rather than the secretary. It said the request “did not accompany any vacancy circular” and cited DoPT instructions issued on Dec 12, 2013, which stated that applications not submitted against an advertised vacancy “should not be forwarded”. The ministry also referred to section 10 of the Lokpal Act, which empowers the Lokpal chairperson to appoint the institution’s staff.
The April 27 circular appeared to address the procedural objection raised in 2022, as Chaturvedi had applied for an advertised vacancy with Uttarakhand govt’s consent. Yet, the exercise was cancelled. The RTI response did not establish whether Chaturvedi’s application influenced the withdrawal decision.
Meanwhile, Centre directly appointed another officer as joint secretary in Lokpal in July 2026, without following the vacancy circular route. The appointment order reportedly included a relaxation of the cooling-off period requirement for the officer.

Information Commission resumes RTI complaint hearings after nearly two years

Dhaka Tribune: Dhaka: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
The Information Commission Bangladesh has resumed hearing complaints filed under the Right to Information (RTI) Act after nearly two years.
The Commission held hearings on five complaints on Monday, disposing of three of them and fixing dates for further hearings on the remaining two.
Chief Information Commissioner Prof Dr Nahreen Islam Khan, along with Information Commissioners S A M Mahfuzur Rahman and Khan Mohammad Abul Hossain, conducted the hearings.
With the Commission remaining non-functional for an extended period, a total of 917 complaints were filed over the past two years. The government reconstituted the Information Commission on October 17.
After assuming office, the newly constituted Commission adopted a 100-day action plan, prioritizing the disposal of pending complaints. As part of the initiative, it is working to expedite the hearing and resolution process.
The complaints heard on Monday concerned the non-disclosure of information relating to recruitment by various public and private institutions, land ownership and income-expenditure accounts of institutions, development projects and allocations of local government bodies, reasons for cancellation of appointment letters, recruitment examination answer scripts, and the leasing of government property.

Punjab Information Commission issues bailable warrants against Aero City SHO in RTI case :Barinderjit Saluja

Times of India: Chandigarh: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
The Punjab Information Commission has ordered the issuance of bailable warrants against the SHO of Bakarpur-Aero City police station in connection with a Right to Information (RTI) case, directing him to appear before the Commission with relevant records and evidence.
In an order dated Nov 5, chief information commissioner Inderpal Singh directed that bailable warrants be issued against the public information officer (PIO)/SHO of the police station. A copy of the order was also sent to the SSP, Mohali, for execution of the warrants.
The PIO has also been given an opportunity to submit a written reply and appear for a personal hearing under relevant sections of the RTI Act before any penalty is imposed.
The commission cautioned that if the PIO neither submits a written reply nor appears for the hearing on the next date, it would be presumed that he has nothing further to state, and the proceedings would continue ex parte.
The matter has been listed for Dec 17, 2026, at 11.30am in Chandigarh.

Tail-end farmers of PAP Main Canal approach Appellate Authority, resent denial of details about Apex Committee sought through RTI query

The Hindu: Tiruppur: Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Not satisfied by ‘evasive’ replies to their query on existence of Apex Committee under the RTI Act by the Water Resources Department, farmers in the tail-end of PAP Main Canal have gone for first appeal under Section 19(1) of the Act. In a representation to the Appellate Authority Officer and joint Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, P. Velusamy, on behalf of the farmers, had sought information on the constitution of the Apex Committee.
The stand taken by the Public Information Officer (PIO) that the information sought extensive/ voluminous and invoked Section 7(9) of the RTI Act, prompted the farmers to go on appeal. The PIO’s reply, Mr. Velusamy said, was ‘incomplete, evasive and legally unsustainable’, and questioned the rationale behind invocation of Section 7(9) of the RTI Act (to deny the details), which is applicable only in situations where the information would disproportionately divert the resources of public authority, or be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record.
The RTI application, Mr. Velusamy pointed out, had asked for identifiable documents, including GO/ notification on constitution of the Apex Committee; appointment/nomination order of the Chairman, present list of members; term/tenure of Chairman and members, official address and contact details; meeting details and minutes; and records establishing the constitution of the Committee after April 21, 2026. The WRD’s reply to an earlier RTI query on this date stated that the Apex Committee has not been constituted, and that its meetings had not taken place during the preceding three years.
The appeal also sought information on the documents/ instructions on the basis of which the learned Special Government Pleader represented before the High Court that the Apex Committee was already in existence and functioning; records relating to the receipt and implementation of the High Court order; action taken on the representation dated March 10, 2026; and relevant government orders, rules and proceedings governing the Apex Committee.
Transparency in these matters is directly connected with public accountability, lawful administration and the interests of thousands of registered ayacutdars dependent upon PAP system, Mr. Velusamy said, requesting the First Appellate Authority to furnish complete information.

Monday, November 16, 2026

RTI Data, Bride 18, groom 19: How a late-night raid stopped a Haryana child marriage - Written by: Sukhbir Siwach

Indian Express: Haryana: Monday, 16 November 2026.
RTI data from the Haryana Women and Child Development Department reveals 4,284 child marriage complaints across the state over the past decade, with Panipat (456), Sirsa (444), and Fatehabad (423) recording the highest numbers.

A late-night intervention stopped a proposed child marriage in Jind after officials found the 19-year-old groom was below the legal marriage age (Express photo/Special arrangement).

A decorated tent had been erected, around 100 wedding guests and members of the procession were having the feast, and pre-wedding rituals were underway just before the pheras (the ceremonial rounds around the sacred fire) when a joint team of officials and activists stepped in to halt a child marriage midway during a late-night intervention in Haryana’s Jind district last month.
The Sonipat unit of Mission to the Desperate and Destitute of India (MDD of India), an associate organisation of Just Rights for Children (JRC) in Haryana, had initially received confidential information that a wedding procession was scheduled to travel from a village in Sonipat district to a village in Jind district.
A team comprising officials from the administrations of Jind and Sonipat districts, police personnel, the Child Marriage Prohibition Officer, and members of MDD of India reached the groom’s village in Sonipat district, only to find the procession had already left for Jind. Rushing to the bride’s home in a village in Jind district, they arrived just in time to stop the ceremony.
The officials immediately halted the rituals and sought the birth certificates of the bride and groom to verify their ages. The bride’s family promptly produced her birth certificate, which established that she was 18 years and five days old. However, the groom’s family delayed producing his documents for nearly two hours. Following firm intervention by the team, his birth certificate was finally produced, revealing that he was only 19 years old.
Under the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, the minimum legal age for marriage is 18 years for women and 21 years for men. Since the groom was below the legally prescribed age, the marriage could not proceed.
Meanwhile, the bride’s family alleged that the groom’s family had misled them about his age and refused to go ahead with the marriage. Both families returned the dowry articles, jewellery and other belongings to each other at the spot, and the wedding procession subsequently returned without the bride.
According to Narendra Sharma, Jind district coordinator of MDD of India, who has been actively associated with efforts to prevent child marriages and promote children’s rights, as many as five suspected child marriage cases had been reported from different villages of Jind district within a week in October.
Following the vigilance of the district child marriage prohibition officer and activists associated with JRC, three marriages were stopped before the ceremonies could take place, while investigations are underway in the remaining two cases where the marriages had already been solemnised.
In another incident on October 16, a team led by Ravi Lohan, Assistant District Child Marriage Prohibition Officer in Jind, stopped the proposed marriages of two cousins in a village in the district. Both wedding processions had arrived from a village in Hisar district, and document verification revealed that both brides and one of the grooms were minors.
In a suspected child marriage case reported on October 17, the authorities could not prevent the marriage as the information reached them after the wedding ceremonies had been completed. The wedding procession, which had arrived from a village in Charkhi Dadri district, had already completed the rituals and returned before the intervention team reached the spot.
Officials later contacted the families by phone, arranged for the bride and groom to be called back while they were still on their way, and handed the bride over to her family while the district administration investigates the matter to verify her age.
Surinder Singh Maan, chief executive officer of MDD of India, said the wedding season had begun in Haryana and that the organisation’s teams would work closely with the district administrations to maintain strict vigilance against child marriages across 21 districts of the state.
Panipat, Sirsa and Fatehabad top complaint tally
Data obtained by Narendra Sharma under the Right to Information (RTI) Act from the Haryana Women and Child Development Department shows that Panipat, Sirsa and Fatehabad have recorded the highest number of child marriage complaints in Haryana over the past decade, with a total of 4,284 complaints reported across the state’s 22 districts between 2015-16 and 2024-25. In most of the reported cases, child marriages were prevented following timely intervention by the authorities and NGOs.
Panipat topped the list with 456 complaints during the period, followed by Sirsa with 444 complaints, while neighbouring Fatehabad recorded 423 and Jind district reported 324 complaints. Asked about the possible reasons behind the comparatively high number of complaints in certain areas, a senior official of the Haryana Women and Child Development Department said that the practice might be prevalent in some specific communities and among migrant families in the districts concerned.
Department Director Priyanka Soni stated, “Social factors remain the primary drivers of child marriage. In relatively developed areas and communities, families tend to delay their children’s marriages until they are settled in life. We have been undertaking awareness campaigns to prevent child marriages and address the social factors contributing to the practice.”
She added that Haryana has 13 District Protection-cum-Prohibition Officers entrusted with preventing child marriages at the district level and ensuring the protection, care and welfare of affected children.
Meanwhile, Bhuwan Ribhu, founder of Just Rights for Children (JRC), stated that the organisation aims to eradicate the social evils of child marriage and forced marriage from India by 2030. Highlighting that over 250 civil society organisations associated with JRC are actively working on the ground across all 782 districts of the country, he emphasised that JRC would play a proactive and leading role in supporting and strengthening the Government of India’s ‘Bal Vivah Mukt Bharat’ (Child Marriage-Free India) campaign.
District-wise Child Marriage Complaints in Haryana (2015-16 to 2024-25)
Ambala: 127
Bhiwani: 129
Charkhi Dadri: 16
Faridabad: 135
Fatehabad: 423
Gurgaon: 50
Hisar: 283
Jhajjar: 65
Jind: 324
Kaithal: 214
Karnal: 269
Kurukshetra: 126
Mahendragarh: 127
Mewat: 377
Palwal: 151
Panipat: 456
Panchkula: 31
Rewari: 79
Rohtak: 148
Sirsa: 444
Sonipat: 188
Yamunanagar: 122
Total: 4,284
Source: Haryana Women and Child Development Department
Period: 2015-16 to 2024-25

RTI : BMC Acted Against Only 15.6% of Illegal Construction Complaints Over 10 Years

Clarion India: Mumbai: Monday, 16 November 2026.
An RTI reply shows that the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation received 98,689 original complaints over a decade, but carried out demolition action in only 13,211 cases
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) took demolition action in only 13,211 cases out of 98,689 original complaints about illegal constructions received over the past 10 years, according to information obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
The figures, obtained by RTI activist Shakeel Ahmed Sheikh, raise questions about the municipal body’s handling of complaints against unauthorised constructions and the functioning of its online Real Estate Tracking Management System (RETMS), which was introduced to receive complaints and facilitate action against such structures.
According to the information supplied by the BMC, it received a total of 214,917 complaints during the 10 years. Of these, 116,229 were repeat complaints, while the number of original complaints was recorded as 98,689.
Demolition action was carried out in 13,211 cases, amounting to approximately 15.6 per cent of the original complaints.
The BMC’s figures also provide details of notices issued and the subsequent stages of action. A total of 60,332 notices were prepared against the original complaints, of which 57,521 were issued. The civic body also issued 31,486 show-cause notices.
Demolition was considered necessary in 29,916 cases. The arrangements for demolition were reported to be pending in 15,318 cases, while arrangements had been made in 1,387 cases. Actual demolition action was carried out in 13,211 cases.
The figures raise questions about the gap between cases in which demolition was considered necessary and those in which the civic body actually acted. The RTI activist has called for the BMC to make the present status of all pending cases public and explain the action being taken in each of them.
The ward-wise figures also show considerable differences in the number of complaints and demolition action.
L Ward recorded the highest number of complaints, with 30,935 cases. However, demolition action was taken in only 637 cases.
K East Ward received 24,064 complaints, of which 1,325 resulted in demolition action. M East Ward recorded 14,510 complaints, but action was taken in just 159 cases. P South Ward received 14,424 complaints, with demolition action reported in 1,932 cases.
The figures for L Ward are particularly striking: despite having the highest number of complaints, the number of demolitions remained relatively low.
Sheikh questioned the BMC’s handling of illegal constructions and the gap between notices and actual enforcement.
“The BMC’s Building and Factory Department has been taking action against illegal constructions for a long time. Crores of rupees are spent every year, yet illegal constructions continue to receive protection?” he asked.
He said more than 15,000 notices were issued annually, but the rate of actual demolition remained very low.
“Why is actual action not taken after notices are issued? What disciplinary action has been taken against officials who fail to act? How many times have responsible officers protecting illegal constructions been suspended? The public should be given answers to these questions,” Sheikh said.
He has written to Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Municipal Commissioner Ashwini Bhide, urging them to initiate demolition action against pending illegal constructions without further delay.
He has also demanded the suspension of officials and employees found responsible and strict action against them.
The RTI figures come at a time when the Maharashtra government has spoken of its ambition to transform Mumbai into a city comparable to Shanghai. The findings raise questions about the BMC’s enforcement of building regulations and its ability to address complaints of unauthorised construction across the city.

RTI Act can help curb misinformation: CIC

Daily Observer: Bangladesh: Monday, 16 November 2026.
Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) Prof Dr Nahreen Islam Khan on Sunday said information gaps, secrecy and limited access to reliable sources fuel the spread of misinformation and disinformation, noting that the Right to Information (RTI) Act can play a crucial role in curbing them.
She made the remarks while addressing, as the chief guest, the Information Integrity Conference 2026, organised by Dataful at the Bishwo Shahitto Kendro in Dhaka with the theme “Breaking the Web of Disinformation”.
The CIC said information gaps, a tendency to conceal information and a lack of easy access to reliable sources often create opportunities for the spread of disinformation and misinformation.
 With the rapid spread of information through social media and digital platforms, it often becomes difficult for ordinary people to distinguish between true, false, misleading and deliberately distorted information, creating confusion and negative impacts at personal, societal and state levels, she added.
“The right to information is itself a human right and an important means of empowering people,” Nahreen said, stressing that effective implementation of the Right to Information Act, 2009 is crucial to ensuring transparency and accountability in government activities and establishing good governance." UNB

Payment history is not reachable, PWD tells RTI activist : By Swapnil R Mishra

Mumbai Mirror: Mumbai: Monday, 16 November 2026.
But directive from appellate authority may still put dept’s books under the scanner

RTI activist Yusuf Khan

The state Public Works Department (PWD) has stonewalled an Right to Information (RTI) activist’s efforts to examine tendering process, payments and work allocation on a technicality the department refused to divulge the details claiming that the information was not available in the particular format sought, apart from citing exemptions under the RTI Act.
However, PWD’s resistance to an open, public examination of its records faced a setback when its first appellate authority directed officials to allow inspection of competitive tender rates and specified tender documents in separate RTI cases filed by the same activist.
The RTI applications that the PWD refused to answer were filed by Yusuf Khan with the PWD’s Integrated Unit (Civil) Division in Mumbai. Khan sought payment vouchers, payment slips, work orders, bills and tender-related information concerning works undertaken under different government budget heads.
The 2 RTI queries PWD rejected
In one application, he sought payment vouchers and payment slips linked to individual contractors for works under budget heads 2059 and 2216, the District Planning and Development Committee (DPDC) budget and MOW-related works.
“When public funds are spent on government works, there should be no ambiguity about who received the money and against which work. Citizens have every right to seek accountability for public expenditure. The department cannot cite the format of information sought to deny access to records it holds,” Khan said.
The PWD rejected the request, stating that payment details were not maintained in the format sought. It referred to Sections 2(f) and 2(j) of the RTI Act, 2005, which define information accessible under the law and the right to access records held by public authorities.
However, the rejection did not clarify whether Khan could inspect individual payment vouchers and slips available with the department, even if a consolidated contractor-wise statement was not maintained.
In another application, Khan sought work orders and bills relating to three construction agencies — M/s Nivrutti Anna Patole, M/s Meru Construction and M/s Dhanlakshmi Construction — for the financial years 2022-23 to 2025-26.
The PWD denied the information, invoking Sections 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, which provide exemptions relating to commercial confidence and personal information. The department cited the possibility of disclosure affecting the agencies’ commercial interests and maintained that Khan had not established a larger public interest warranting disclosure.
“Government expenditure cannot be placed beyond public scrutiny merely by invoking commercial confidence or personal information. If the department believes that a particular record attracts an exemption, it must justify withholding it under the provisions of the RTI Act. Public money and the payments made against public works require accountability,” Khan said.
Appellate authority steps in
In contrast, the PWD’s first appellate authority, in two separate proceedings, directed officials to facilitate Yusuf Khan’s inspection of tender records.
In one case, the authority directed the department to permit inspection of records containing percentage-based competitive rates quoted in online open tenders. The application covered tender notices issued over a three-year period. Officials were also directed to provide the specified information within 30 days, without charging a fee, subject to the conditions mentioned in the order.
A similar direction was issued in a separate case concerning offline tender notices. Officials were instructed to allow inspection of relevant records relating to a specified work and provide the requested information within 30 days, without charging a fee.
“An appellate order has to be complied with within the stipulated time. The department will have to examine the records covered by the directions and facilitate inspection in accordance with the order. However, disclosure of payment-related documents and other records has to be considered separately, keeping in view the provisions and exemptions under the RTI Act,” a PWD official said, requesting anonymity.
“The appellate orders are significant because they recognise that existing government records must be accessible to citizens. Tender rates and related documents are essential to understanding how public contracts are awarded. Transparency must extend to scrutiny of expenditure and payments made against the work,” Khan said.
The appellate orders, however, apply to the specified tender-related records and do not constitute a blanket direction to disclose all documents sought in the other RTI applications.
Senior PWD officials did not respond to Mirror’s request for comment till press time.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

गुरुग्राम के तहसीलदार-नायब तहसीलदार पर ₹50 हजार जुर्माना:RTI की जानकारी नहीं देने पर आयोग सख्त; पेंशन से भी हो सकती है वसूली

Dainik Bhaskar: Gurugram: Sunday, 15 November 2026.
राज्य सूचना आयोग ने आरटीआई एक्ट के तहत मांगी गई जानकारी देने में लापरवाही और देरी बरतने के मामले में गुरुग्राम के दो राजस्व अधिकारियों पर
₹50 हजार का जुर्माना लगाया है। इसके साथ ही संबंधित सक्षम प्राधिकारी को इन अधिकारियों के खिलाफ सेवा नियमों के तहत उचित अनुशासनात्मक कार्रवाई शुरू करने के भी सख्त निर्देश दिए हैं।
शिकायतकर्ता हरेंद्र ढींगड़ा का कहना है कि आयोग ने एक अन्य आरटीआई आवेदन से जुड़ी शिकायत के मामले में पहले ही इन अधिकारियों की जिम्मेदारी तय करने और धारा 20(2) के तहत उचित अनुशासनात्मक कार्रवाई करने के निर्देश दिए थे। इसके बावजूद, निर्धारित समय सीमा के भीतर सूचना उपलब्ध न कराने को आयोग ने गंभीरता से लिया।

आयोग ने 2005 की धारा 20(1) के तहत अधिकारियों को जवाबदेह ठहराया।

अधिकारियों की जवाबदेह
राज्य सूचना आयोग ने आरटीआई अधिनियम, 2005 की धारा 20(1) के तहत वैधानिक शर्तों को पूरा पाते हुए तत्कालीन अधिकारियों को जवाबदेह ठहराया। आयोग ने साल 2024 में ‘शो कॉज नोटिस’ संख्या 1464 और 1468 पर फैसला सुनाते हुए तहसीलदार दर्पण कंबोज और नायब तहसीलदार सुशील कुमार पर 25-25 हजार रुपए का जुर्माना किया है।
ये दोनों अधिकारी 7 नवंबर 2022 को दाखिल किए गए आरटीआई आवेदन के समय राज्य लोक सूचना अधिकारी का प्रभार संभाल रहे थे और मामले से सीधे तौर पर जुड़े हुए थे।

आरटीआई के माध्यम से मांगी गई जानकारी का पत्र।

पेंशन से वसूली जा सकती है जुर्माना राशि
आयोग ने अपने आदेश में स्पष्ट किया है कि जुर्माने की यह राशि आदेश मिलने के तीन महीने के भीतर आयोग के निर्दिष्ट हेड या स्टेट इंफॉर्मेशन कमिशन के पक्ष में डिमांड ड्राफ्ट के माध्यम से पंचकूला में जमा करानी होगी।
आयोग सचिवालय को इस आदेश की प्रति गुरुग्राम के उपायुक्त को भेजने के निर्देश दिए गए हैं, जो अधिकारियों से इस राशि की वसूली सुनिश्चित करेंगे। आयोग ने सख्त रुख अपनाते हुए यह भी कहा है कि यदि संबंधित अधिकारी रिटायर हो चुके हैं, तो कानून के अनुसार यह जुर्माना राशि उनकी पेंशन से वसूल की जाए।
3 महीने में मांगी कार्रवाई की रिपोर्ट
आदेश के तहत उच्च अधिकारियों को यह भी निर्देश दिया गया है कि वे इस बात की गहन जांच करें कि आखिर सूचना देने में देरी किन परिस्थितियों की वजह से हुई। देरी, लापरवाही और कर्तव्य में ढिलाई बरतने वाले अधिकारियों के खिलाफ विभागीय सेवा नियमों के तहत बिना किसी देरी के उचित अनुशासनात्मक कार्रवाई की जाए।
इस कार्रवाई की रिपोर्ट अगले तीन महीनों के भीतर राज्य सूचना आयोग को सौंपनी होगी। इसके साथ ही यह सुनिश्चित करने की हिदायत दी है कि भविष्य में हर आरटीआई आवेदन का निपटारा आरटीआई अधिनियम, 2005 में तय की गई वैधानिक समय सीमा के भीतर ही किया जाए।

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Beyond Ramps: How Dr. Arvinder Singh’s RTI Campaign Is Exposing the Real State of Banking Accessibility in India

News X: National: Saturday, 14 November 2026.
Dr. Arvinder Singh
A ramp at the entrance has become the default proof that a bank branch is accessible. It is also, increasingly, the wrong place to stop looking. Beyond that single ramp lie teller counters designed for standing customers, biometric authentication that assumes steady hands and clear vision, net banking portals that lack screen-reader support, and KYC processes that quietly exclude anyone who cannot complete them in the expected way. These gaps affect the everyday lives of customers with disabilities and are increasingly being documented through a Right to Information (RTI) campaign that has brought banking accessibility concerns onto the institutional record.
The campaign is led by Dr. Arvinder Singh, a Udaipur-based physician, healthcare entrepreneur, and disability rights activist whose broader disability rights work has involved more than 700 RTI applications, including applications examining how banks implement accessibility requirements in practice. The campaign, run through Panacea Disability Rights Activists (PDRA), an initiative of the Panacea Educational Society, has resulted in documented institutional responses and accessibility-related interventions involving banks.
What the RTI responses actually show
Bank of India and RBL Bank have both been associated with accessibility-related interventions following concerns raised through the campaign. These responses indicate how documented accessibility concerns can lead to institutional action. The method behind these results is deliberately unglamorous. Rather than public campaigns or media pressure as a first move, Dr. Singh uses the RTI Act as a diagnostic instrument: a formal, documented inquiry that requires an institution to state, on record, what it has or has not implemented.
That distinction matters. A complaint can be dismissed. An RTI response becomes part of the institutional record, and a pattern of RTI responses across hundreds of branches becomes difficult to explain away as isolated oversights.
The findings from Udaipur offer specific examples. In its responses to RTI applications, Bank of India reported gaps in ramp access, wheelchair facilities, tactile paths, and accessible toilets across the five branches examined. The bank also stated that work on the ramps and wheelchair access had been initiated after the applications.
PNB’s responses offer another example of the difference between providing an individual accessibility facility and ensuring that a branch is fully accessible. The bank reported that all 51 branches under its Udaipur Mandal had ramps or wheelchair-accessible entrances, but none had been declared fully accessible. It also reported that an accessibility audit of branches in the district had not been conducted.
Why banking, and why now?
Bank branches sit at an unusual intersection: they provide essential public-facing services and are subject to applicable accessibility requirements, including standards specific to the banking sector. That dual status has historically made enforcement inconsistent. Audits may take place, but accountability for what those audits find has been harder to establish. Digital banking has compounded the problem. A net banking interface without screen-reader compatibility, or a KYC workflow that does not accommodate customers with different disabilities, can exclude a customer just as effectively as a missing ramp, while attracting far less scrutiny.
Dr. Singh’s campaign is still active, and not every bank has responded in the same way. PNB has provided RTI responses identifying accessibility gaps, while the matter involving HDFC Bank has progressed to a civil court summons concerning accessibility arrangements and access to banking services at a branch. These developments indicate that institutional responses and the pace of change can vary across banks.
A perspective shaped by more than advocacy
Dr. Singh’s perspective on accessibility is also shaped by his lived experience.  He lives with a locomotor disability resulting from childhood polio, giving his work a first-person understanding of precisely where infrastructure fails. He has also spent more than two decades building and leading healthcare and diagnostics organizations, including senior roles at Dr. Lal PathLabs and Piramal Diagnostics. This experience gives him an understanding of institutional operations alongside his perspective as someone seeking accountability from outside these institutions.
His work brings together lived experience, institutional understanding, and the use of formal mechanisms such as the RTI Act to document accessibility gaps. An RTI campaign that documents specific accessibility concerns can give institutions a clearer basis for considering corrective measures, rather than relying solely on public criticism.
What it signals for the sector
The challenge ahead is whether acknowledgment at the institutional level translates into changes that customers actually experience: branches that are genuinely navigable, staff trained to assist customers rather than improvise, and digital banking tools built for more than one kind of user. Dr. Singh’s broader body of work extending to transport, public institutions, and policing suggests that banking is one front in a longer, methodical effort to make accessibility compliance something that can be verified, rather than merely claimed.
For the banking sector, the lesson from this campaign is that accessibility cannot be assessed through a checklist or the presence of a single facility. A sustained, well-documented RTI effort can achieve what years of general awareness messaging often cannot. It can put institutions on record, in their own words, admitting that the work is incomplete, and in doing so, it begins to close the gap between what accessibility policies promise and what customers actually encounter at bank branches.

Biogas plant under construction at Vellalore dumpyard lacks TNPCB consent: RTI reply -By Sibi Sreevathson T.C.

The Hindu: Coimbatore: Saturday, 14 November 2026.
A biogas plant, designed to process 250 tonnes of waste a day, is under construction at the Vellalore dumpyard in Coimbatore without the consent of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board (TNPCB), according to information obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.

The 250-tonne-a-day biogas plant being developed at the Vellalore dumpyard in Coimbatore.

In a reply dated November 11, 2026, M.S. Vinodhkumar, District Environmental Engineer, TNPCB, Coimbatore, stated that no application had been received from the project for consent from the board. The information was sought by K.S. Mohan, secretary of the Kurichi-Vellalore Pollution Prevention Action Committee.
The project, estimated to cost ₹69 crore, is being implemented by the Coimbatore Corporation. According to Corporation sources, construction began in March this year, with an 18-month period stipulated for completion.
However, only 25% of the work has been completed so far. The Corporation has issued a notice to the contractor over the slow pace of construction, the sources said.
Mr. Mohan alleged that the project is taken forward without adhering to the National Green Tribunal’s (NGT) directions on decentralised waste processing. Plans should not be drawn up to transport the entire city’s waste to the Vellalore dumpyard instead of processing it at decentralised facilities, in view of the tribunal’s directions. He also questioned the Corporation for commencing construction without applying for the mandatory Consent to Establish (CTE) from the TNPCB.
Residents living near the Vellalore dumpyard were enduring unbearable foul odour emanating from the legacy waste and existing waste-processing units. The Corporation had failed to address their complaints or find a lasting solution and was now taking up another project without obtaining the necessary pollution control consent, he alleged.
Corporation Commissioner Katta Ravi Teja said the BioCNG plant was classified under the White Category and was therefore exempt from the conventional Consent to Establish (CTE) and Consent to Operate (CTO) requirements under the Water and Air Acts. Industries falling under this category were not required to obtain these consents from the TNPCB, he said.

RTI Applicant Reprimanded Over Alleged Harassment of Women Doctors

Deccan Chronicle: New Delhi: Saturday, 14 November 2026.
The Andhra Pradesh State Information Commission dismissed an RTI applicant’s complaint against two women doctors, citing allegations of intimidation and harassment under the pretext of seeking information.
The Andhra Pradesh State Information Commission has dismissed a complaint filed by an RTI applicant against two women doctors at Munnangi Primary Health Centre in Guntur district, taking note of allegations that he had harassed the medical officers under the pretext of seeking information.
A bench comprising commissioners Dr Rehana Begum, Gajula Adenna and V.S.K. Chakravarthy reprimanded the complainant, Maddirala Subba Rao, over his alleged conduct towards Dr Neha and Dr Priyanka.
The commission took note of allegations that Subba Rao and his associates had made threatening phone calls, including late at night, sent intimidating messages and recorded videos and photographs of the doctors without their consent.
The bench observed that the Right to Information Act was intended to ensure transparency and accountability and should not be used as a tool for personal vendetta or harassment.
Referring to the Supreme Court judgment in CBSE versus Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011) 8 SCC 497 and relevant Central Information Commission decisions, the bench said repeated RTI applications should not be used to harass individuals or obstruct the functioning of government officials.
The commission directed the Guntur Superintendent of Police to inquire into the alleged harassment and take appropriate action. It also asked the District Medical and Health Officer to assess the doctors' safety and ensure adequate security at their workplaces, particularly during night duty.
The bench stressed that the RTI Act must be used responsibly and honestly.

Tribal Ministry cites Manipur tensions to refuse RTI on 'Any Kuki Tribes' deletion proposal

The Hindu: New Delhi: Saturday, 14 November 2026.
The RTI applicant referred to a Manipur Government letter which he claimed concerned the proposal to delete the nomenclature 'Any Kuki Tribes' from the State's ST list and correct 'Any Mizo (Lushai) Tribe' to 'Mizo'

Image used for representational purpose only. | Photo Credit: ANI

The Tribal Affairs Ministry has refused to disclose information relating to a claimed Manipur Government proposal to delete the nomenclature 'Any Kuki Tribes' from the Scheduled Tribes list, citing apprehensions that the disclosure could aggravate inter-community tensions in the ethnic violence-hit state.
Information Commissioner Ashutosh Chaturvedi has upheld the Ministry's stand.
The RTI applicant, Michael Haokip, referred to a Manipur Government letter dated July 25, 2024, which he claimed concerned the proposal to delete the nomenclature 'Any Kuki Tribes' from the State's ST list and correct 'Any Mizo (Lushai) Tribe' to 'Mizo'.
The applicant sought confirmation of whether the Ministry had received the proposal, along with its date of receipt and official file number.
He also sought details of the action taken on it and whether it had been forwarded to the Registrar General of India (RGI) and the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes (NCST) for concurrence.
He further sought copies of relevant communications and file notings, besides the names and designations of officials handling the matter since July 2024.
In its reply dated June 24, 2025, the Ministry said it was the nodal ministry for deciding claims relating to inclusion, exclusion and other modifications in the Scheduled Tribes list under Article 342 of the Constitution.
It said proposals recommended and justified by the concerned State Government or Union Territory administration could be processed further and required concurrence from the RGI and NCST before consideration for legislative amendment.
The Ministry said disclosure during the examination and consultation process could exert "undue pressure and influence" on authorities and lead to interference by vested interests in independent decision-making.
It further said it had come across instances where disclosure of information regarding notification of a community had led to violence.
"Such disclosure of information will have the potential to disturb public peace, tranquillity and encourage enmity between the communities," the CPIO said.
During the recent hearing, the Ministry specifically submitted that the matter was sensitive "in view of the ethnic violence and prevailing law-and-order concerns in Manipur following developments concerning the Scheduled Tribe status of communities in the State".
It apprehended that premature disclosure of internal proposals, communications and deliberative records could "aggravate inter-community tensions", exert undue pressure on the authorities concerned and potentially lead to "disturbance of public order and incitement of offences".
The applicant contended that the CPIO's response was vague and failed to explain how basic administrative particulars, including the date of receipt, file number and names of officials, could be treated as information held in a fiduciary capacity. He also argued that the apprehensions regarding public order were general and speculative.
The order said the commission was not persuaded that the public interest in disclosure of substantive internal deliberations and communications outweighed the potential harm identified by the Ministry.
The CIC also considered whether non-sensitive portions of the records could be disclosed after redaction under Section 10 of the RTI Act but ruled out even the limited relief of providing redacted copies of the proposal and related action-taken notings.