Sunday, July 09, 2017

When there’s a will, there will be document trail in every scam

Oherald: Editorial: Sunday, July 09, 2017.
When a vigilance inquiry is recommended, purely based on simple information but dogged work done by Herald in its reportage, there is cause to feel vindicated that the pursuit of news can be a rewarding end itself.
When a vigilance inquiry is recommended, purely based on simple information but dogged work done by Herald in its reportage, there is cause to feel vindicated that the pursuit of news can be a rewarding end itself.
The information which is embedded and yet available in the system, documents every move, every decision and yet every wrong doing. There is one thing about the government and its system. Everything is on file. And therefore, if a government really wants to clean up the stables and go to the bottom of every decision which is not made in the state’s interest, or where the exchequer has been looted, taking with it the trust of the people, there is nothing that can stop it from doing so.
As we apply for and study countless RTI sourced documents, there is a very interesting thread which emerges. Honest bureaucrats have covered their tracks with dissenting remarks, strong objections, advising against taking hasty decisions, while others either out of ignorance or out of design have obeyed wrong orders and find themselves in the dock.
The executive engineer of the Water Resources Department, P B Badami, who was apparently His Masters Voice of then Water Resources Minister Dayanand Mandrekar, is one such officer. Reacting to Herald’s reports on the controversial Siolim jetty project, WRD minister Vinod Palyekar, clearly points at Badami, as the architect of the Siolim jetty scam.
“It is interesting to note how Badami apparently has not conducted or done required ground work before starting such a project. It clearly looks like the said EE PB Badami has acted in haste and as a matter of fact undue haste resulting in stoppage of project,” Palyekar wrote on file, which recommending a vigilance inquiry into the Siolim Jetty project.
As Herald found and the minister acknowledged, there were no permissions from CRZ authorities. The project was pushed in such haste that the department itself wasn’t quite clear what the contract sought to be given, was for. The minister’s notings are clear. “Plans for the project are not placed in the file pertaining to the project which clearly appears that the WRD was not sure what was being constructed through contractor.”
The minister’s words were telling. “I am surprised how WRD could undertake project involving such a huge amount from public exchequer without study and necessary permissions.”
The government of the day, must now ensure that a scam in the allotment of work for the Siolim jetty gets the same attention and seriousness as the scam in the allotment of plots in GIDC or for that matter the purchase of lands disproportionate to the income of the former GIDC chairman, and now Quepem Cong MLA and leader of the opposition, Babu Kavlekar.
Probes into actions involving loss to the exchequer should all get equal treatment, even if former Congress MLAs who were the target of those probes are now BJP MLAs and Ministers.
The only solace here is that in the ocean of decisions, there are banks of documents in public domain. The pursuit of zero tolerance to corruption is not just easy but easily track-able.
So everyone from a senior revenue official caught taking a bribe, to a mining official who looked the other way as illegal ore was smuggled out to a WRD officer who attempted to clear a jetty project under the garb of  repairing bunds, cannot really hide from the system and the trail of documents. All it needs is a government ready to work on the document trail.
As for the people and the media, they have the resources and the law to doggedly pursue the truth. An honest approach sometimes also gets the backing of the government, to at the very least, start a probe.